Tera: Enchanting theorycrafting + statistics data dump thread

[mallister]

yeah my one and only attempt at a +7 (haha yes i know +7 at lvl 47, wtf bother, etc) was a resounding failure and kind of a surprise; figured burning a gold on it would be a high chance of sucess. then again, the amount of golds that have dropped to me in the last 2 lvl's from questline alone is pretty surprising, so it's not like they're rare candy or anything, either.

[Coren]

They're rarer, and more expensive, at 60. :/

[Coren]

Lvl 60 gold weapon, soporcircus
white, pass to +1
white, fail
white, pass to +2
white, fail x 2
white, pass to +3
white, fail x 2
white, pass to +4
green, fail x 6
green, pass to +5
green, fail x 10
gold, fail (wtfff)

[Coren]

lvl 19, green weapon (tier 3)
white, pass to +1
white, pass to +2
green, pass to +3

Lvl 22 blue weapon (tier 4), bloodstrike
white, pass to +1
white, pass to +2
white, pass to +3
white, fail
green, pass to +4
green, fail
green, pass to +5
green, fail
green, fail
green, pass to +6

[Coren]

lvl 60 weapon continued, starts at +5
white fail
green fail x11
green, pass to +6
gold, pass to +7

[MaachaQ]

Blue level 38 gloves for Mystic. I didn't feel the +1 crit on gold gloves at that level compared to the blue was worth 65g, especially with how poor I still am ^^;

I only used other blues to upgrade, there were no greens or whites on the broker and I didn't have any saved >.> I was passing time waiting for CR instance match and thought I'd give upgrading a try. Each blue cost me ~2g.

+1 success
+2 success
+3 fail
+3 success
+4 success
+5 fail
+5 success
+6 success

[Coren]

lvl 60 boots, starting at +5
greens, fail x 7
gold, fail

[Coren]

lvl 60 hands, starting at 0
white, pass to +1
white, pass to +2
white, pass to +3
white, fail x 2
green, pass to +4
green, fail x 6

[Coren]

All data to this point has been added to the spreadsheet. Please do not edit any prior posts to add anything.

And everybody else, post shit! Arg!

[Coren]

lvl60 boots, starting +5
green fail x3

lvl60 hands, starting +4
green fail x2
green, pass to +5
green, fail x 2
green, pass to +6 (holy fuck, batman, only 3 tries?)
gold, pass to +7

[Senji]

All T11: g = green S = superior

Boot:
w +1
w +2
w fail x2
w +3
w fail x5
g +4
g fail x3
g +5
g fail x3
b fail x1
g +6

Glove:
w +1
w +2
w fail x1
w +3
w fail x3
w +4
w fail x18
g fail x9
g +5
g+6

Weapon:
w +1
w fail x2
w +2
w fail x1
w +3
w fail x4
w +4
w fail x1
w +5
w fail x10
g fail x1
S +6

Body:
+4 start
g fail x4
g +5
w fail x2
g fail x13
S fail x1

[Rasengan]

T12 Weapon starting at +6 (using only golds):
fail
fail
fail
fail
+7
fail
+8
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
fail
+9!

1/34 from +8...

[madpersian]

Gold 50 weapon:

White +1
White +2
White fail
White fail
White fail
Green +3
Green fail
Green +4
Green fail
Green fail
Green fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Gold +5
Gold +6
Gold fail

Gold 50 gloves

White +1
White fail
White +2
White fail
Green fail
Green +3
Green fail
Green fail
Blue fail
Blue +4
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue +5
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail
Blue fail

[Coren]

lvl 60 boots, green fail at +5

lvl 60 hands, gold fail at +7

[Senji]

T12:
w +1
w +2
w +3
w fail x17
w +4
w fail x11
w +5
w fail x8

Comparing lists against some [much shorter] lower tier twink equips; might be an alkhest check ie more chances to fail the check the more you have.

[Scythiroth]

T5 Lancer/Berserker Feet: (Starting at +4, wasn't keeping track before that >.< )
White: fail x5
Green: fail x5
Blue: +5
Blue: +6

Does armor or weapon type make any difference in chances to succeed? I know no one has been keeping track of that, but those two completes in a row were the same armor type as the feet I was trying to enchant.

[Senji]

Does armor or weapon type make any difference in chances to succeed? I know no one has been keeping track of that, but those two completes in a row were the same armor type as the feet I was trying to enchant.

I didn't write it down, but Ive noticed type and individual ilvls do not seem to matter.

[Scythiroth]

Just making sure! I've never really paid much attention to it while enchanting, but after all of the crazy conspiracy theories related to crafting in FF11, who knows.

[Senji]

We are all definitely tainted by FFXI maths and complexities.

[Coren]

Everything to here is entered.

For what it's worth, there's enough data that it's not completely useless now. Of course, when you figure that my shitty luck is skewing the data....

Including every item level (lower levels are higher % pass rate, but I'm discounting those at the moment):

Whites appear very near 100% from 0. They drop to around 70% for the +1, then ~43% for +2, then 14% for +3. They are a terribad 6% for +4, and nobody so far has succeeded in this thread with a white +5 to get the +6.

Greens are obviously better than whites to +3, but I have too little data on those. At +4, greens appear to be around 14%, and then 8% for the +5.

Blues aren't used very much, but appear to be around 27% at +4 and 6% at +5. Low sample size is throwing the results here I'm sure.

Last, I don't have much data on golds yet, but they seen to be around 60% to go from +5 to +6, and maybe around 37% for the +6 to +7. I have less than 10 gold attempts for each enchant level, so take those numbers with a grain of salt.

One common attempt across all grades attempted, from +4 to +5, shows whites are about 6%, greens are about 13%, blues are about 27%, and golds are better (1/1 so far, woo!).