Right, discount the SS because it has no bearing on a War vs. Pld issue. Also, regularly and generally are pretty much the same. Which is it? The highest I've gotten flipped for was 4.7, and the lowest, barring SS and obvious dodges, is 1.1 on a parry. Were you parrying your <1K MBs? I'm talking flat defense, not parry, because Plds can parry AND block. You say your normal is roughly 3k. A plds average in similar gear is far lower than 3k.
@Foj: Ask if any coil-ready War asked for enmity buffs in any way, shape or form. SE's overreacting on that one, but it affects the standard coil War in no way, shape or form. What bads do with bad buffs is on them, not me.