After a long time trying to get Temperance our LS finally had it pop on our way to the monk Ix'aern and got the virtue so we gathered to do Hope the next night.
As usual we did some research on what we were up against and set our parties up to try to deal with thundaga and burst II the best we could.
Paladin trades the triggers to the ??? at like 8:00 earthday with no weather effect, Hope pops out of the water and.......does nothing. Bards keep using thunder carol and whitemages casting barthunder, mages not going overboard to avoid pulling hate and eating a big thundaga, but it never casts a single spell. It doesn't even attack fast and the weapon skills it's using don't even seem to be really doing anything. Everyone is wondering what is going on and waiting for it to go nuts as it's HP drops or something, but it just never does. A very few short and anticlimatic minutes after it pops it dies and drops only a damn staff.
Has anybody else had this happen? Was it the fact that it was earthday and it is (I'm assuming) a thunder mob and SE has some obsession with elements in sea? If anyone has had this happen, did it start actually casting magic when earthday was over (water day is next I believe)? And did the fact that we killed it on a day when it was honestly about as difficult as the monk Ix'aern with 1 HQ organ affect drop rate?