Originally Posted by
Niiro
What you described is similar to an idea I had for how they should have handled the materia system overall.
Basically, there would be no such thing as RA/EX dropped gear, everything would be crafted items with special NM/stonghold/etc ra/ex materia melded to it.
Instead of Ifrit dropping weapons, he'd drop materia. The materia would be ra/ex and could be placed in a weapon, endowing it with the appropriate abilities depending on the weapon (ie. it'd give DoW weapons ATK and DoM Matk) while also changing the weapon to appear as the ifrit-ized version. Essentially all ra/ex gear as we know it would work that way, putting ra/ex materia into a regular piece of gear turns it into a ra/ex armor with the stats/appearance of the unique item it's based on.
I brainstormed a whole progression system and how multi-melds, materia removal, and materia strengthening would work but it wouldn't be worth the time to type. It would be nothing more than "wasted potential" fan fiction or something.