Quote Originally Posted by Raldo View Post
Hey there all you DoL fans! I come bearing data!

I've tested every gathering value from 231 to 296, and included a few of my data points that aren't consecutive in case that helps someone else down the road.

The following testing is done by a Lv50 Botanist at a Lv45 Lush Vegetation.

Code:
Lv45 (Dart Frog)      - 65    | 66    | 68    | 70    | 72    | 73    |    75   |    77   |    79   |    80   |    82   |    84   |    86   |    87   |    89   |    91   | 93    | 94    | 96    | 98    |
Lv44 (Rolanberry)     - 66    | 68    | 70    | 72    | 73    | 75    |    77   |    79   |    80   |    82   |    84   |    86   |    87   |    89   |    91   |    93   | 94    | 96    | 98    | 100   |
Lv43 (ESTIMATION)     - 68    | 70    | 72    | 73    | 75    | 77    |    79   |    80   |    82   |    84   |    86   |    87   |    89   |    91   |    93   |    94   | 96    | 98    | 100   | 100   |
Lv42 (Black Scorpion) - 70    | 72    | 73    | 75    | 77    | 79    |    80   |    82   |    84   |    86   |    87   |    89   |    91   |    93   |    94   |    96   | 98    | 100   | 100   | 100   |
Lv41 (Sagolii Sage)   - 72    | 73    | 75    | 77    | 79    | 80    |    82   |    84   |    86   |    87   |    89   |    91   |    93   |    94   |    96   |    98   | 100   | 100   | 100   | 100   |
Gathering Stat        - 192   | EST   | EST   | EST   | 219   | EST   | ???~233 | 234~240 | 241~247 | 248~254 | 255~261 | 262~269 | 270~276 | 277~284 | 285~291 | 292~??? | 301   | 314   | EST   | 324   |

Minimum Tested Consecutive Value  - 231
Maximum Tested Consecutive Value  - 296
EST means the column was not explicitly tested, and is estimated on the surrounding info.
There was no Lv43 item available at the testing point, so its row values have all been estimated.
The Earth Shard present had a 100% success rate at all tested gathering values.
Yes, every value between each "~" has the exact same success rate for all items.
No, at no point was I ever able to get a success rate of 76, 78, 81, etc. for any item.
You'll notice that for every item, they always go 75 > 77 > 79 > 80 > 82 > 84 > 86 > 87 > 89 > etc.

If I had to guess what's going on based on my data so far, it seems that there's a set ladder of success values, and you go up a rung on the ladder for all items every +x points of gathering, and for every level of an item, you go down a tier. I was originally going to say that for every +7 gathering, you go up a tier, but for some reason the 277~284 gathering block is a span of 8 gathering, so there must be some small variations from time to time, but you should get the general gist of how gathering success rates work from this data.
Thanks for the data