I didn't full on like cry or anything during the game, but a lot of the moments were so well done that at quite a few times I teared up a number of times. Eagle Flies, Arthur's Outcome, John proposing to Abigail, etc. such a well written game. It will be tough to "top".
I am so fucking happy that Sadie and Charles lived through the end and at the very least they hopefully got happy endings. For a video game I felt such fierce loyalty to them as NPC's. And to John/Arthur it's ridiculous. Like they were real fucking people. Christ. Then watching the credits and actually watching them and seeing how many people put in work to the game was astounding.
I honestly wouldn't mind if they went back like 15 years prior if they make another game. See the gang at their height. But that's a topic for another day.