This recipe is 99.9% accurate. I posted this back in my Screenshot Thread on FFXIOnline. An excerpt:
As for the Sha'ir set, there is already some pieces on sale. I told my Bard LS member last night. To be more specific, the leg & hands recipes are readily available on our server. The other recipes are known but the items have yet to be discovered. You can thank the patch for giving the new recipes. I read a Japanese database quite often and they've already figured which synthesis types are required for the Barone & Sha'ir sets (as well as many other crafts). For specific recipes however, they compiled as much data as they could. Oh and by the way, the Sha'ir Manteel Goldsmithing. The Shining Cloth rumor is false (so kudos to the dumbass that started a false rumor... this is why I don't believe anything until it is verified by a credible source. I don't even get involved in those "speculation" threads on any forum.) For those of you that are bards and are curious, here are the recipes for the known Sha'ir pieces if you want to try to craft them yourself.
Sha'ir Crakows (Feet):
Level 91 Leathercraft - Requires Support of Clothcraft & Goldsmithing (Levels Unknown)
Orichalcum Ingot x 1
Gold Thread x 1
Velvet Cloth x 1
Tiger Leather x 2
Buffalo Leather
Sha'ir Seraweels (Legs):
Level 92 Clothcraft - Requires Support of Leathercraft (Level Unknown)
Gold Thread x 1
Velvet Cloth x 3
Tiger Leather x 1
Tafetta Cloth x 1
Sha'ir Turban (Head):
Level 90 Clothcraft - Requires Support of Goldsmithing (Level Unknown)
Gold Thread x 1
Velvet Cloth x 3
Pigeon's Blood x 1
Hippogryph Feather x 1
Sha'ir Gages (Hands):
Level Unknown Leathercraft - Requires Support of Goldsmithing & Clothcraft (Levels Unknown)
Gold Ingot x 1
Garnet x 1
Gold Thread x 1
Velvet Cloth x 1
Tiger Leather x 1
H.Q. Bugard Skin x 1
Pigeon's Blood x 1
Hippogryph Feather x 1
Sha'ir Manteel (Body):
Level Unknown Goldsmithing - Requires Support of Clothcraft (Level Unknown)
Gold Sheet x 1
Ruby x 1
Sapphire x 1
Gold Thread x 2
Velvet Cloth x 2
Cashmere Cloth x 1
I wonder how much that Cashmere cloth will be...