input please....

[rooster]

AABCNM - 10

kb BCNM99 - 8
faf BCNM99 - 6
adman BCNM99 - 10

Golden-Tongued Culberry - 3
Geush Urvan - 8
Gration - 6
Amaltheia - 8


This is what we have come up with so far... if you think these are fair, say so...

and if you think it should be change speak now... and explain why you think so.... 2 days till i put it in.

[Aratharn]

Sounds good.

[Hirronimus]

Is Adamantoise BC that much harder than Aspi?

Why 10 points for AA BC?

Also I think you should break up HNMs into categories. Someone mentioned about the difficulty of some HNMs being a lot less harder than they were before. Some NMs are duo-able some still require alliance.

My idea for categories is:

CoP Wyrms
Kings (Faf/Nid. KB/Beh. Aspi/Adaman. Beastmen Kings)
Gods/Sky (That probably should include AA BC)
Ground poppable.
Ground 24 hour spawns.

The idea behind it, is to show Linkshells capability and their progress.

[berticus]

I think we're going on hearsay for the aspid bc, and what we've heard is that it's tons harder than regular aspid. Just from the look of it, regular aspid cant cast blink-raping ga spells as well as 1shotmegafkoff waterga4. I heard its regen is even more intense too. It's just guess work unless someone who's done it comes out and says how it is.

[Aratharn]

It is real difficult. We did it a few months ago and took it to 20%.

I'm sure we could win now though.

[Fira]

My Ls doesn't give points for BC99 or these new NM's. Not really sure why. ;3

[Aratharn]

My Ls doesn't give points for BC99 or these new NM's. Not really sure why. ;3

He said he's gonna add it in a couple days!

[NynJa]

8 seems a little high for Amaltheia imo.

[Zigma]

AABCNM - 10

kb BCNM99 - 8
faf BCNM99 - 6
adman BCNM99 - 10

Golden-Tongued Culberry - 3
Geush Urvan - 8
Gration - 6
Amaltheia - 8


This is what we have come up with so far... if you think these are fair, say so...

and if you think it should be change speak now... and explain why you think so.... 2 days till i put it in.

kb BCNM99 - 6
faf BCNM99 - 8
sounds better,

people still wipe to the wyrm because they don't know what to do when it goes up in the air. It also takes a bit more strategy then going into the KB one and just running back to front and so on

aspidoBC is just crazy unless you know how to interrupt his regen. Took it down to about 20-30% before running out of time. Very very hard.

[Nicholas]

I have a question about these points...is this just a BG thing, or is this how LS's across servers score up points to rate your Big Kill list. If so, do you just take their word for it, or ask for screenshots or what? I mean, my sky LS kills Kirin 3x a week (we go one night for 4 hours and do 3 pops). We do all the gods throughout the week leading up to him. We also do the Behemoth BCNM regularly (we buy orbs from people for 3m, and keep all the drops). Assuming all this, how would we go about applying for this list? My server is severely underrepresented on your list!!

[layoneil]

it's points for the Big Kills list, we don't use points in BG.

just sign up on the front. screenshots are preferred but you don't need to screenshot everything. it's obvious someone that has a screen shot of killing Kirin can kill Genbu.

it doesn't matter how many times you've killed a single HNM, just that your LS has done it before which shows it's capable of doing it.

and it's on the honor system, if your LS hasn't killed King Arthro than don't put it on the list.

we've had some entries where people claimed they've killed everything with no screenshots, we will delete those.

[Marcatil]

I haven't actually done the DM fight yet, but...isn't 10 a bit much? I mean, 18 BLMs can basically win that thing in a few seconds @.@

[Aratharn]

I haven't actually done the DM fight yet, but...isn't 10 a bit much? I mean, 18 BLMs can basically win that thing in a few seconds @.@

Try it with a normal setup, without 18 BLM. The fight itself is definately harder than KB or Aspid, so yes 10 is fine for that. If you haven't done it - don't comment on it~

[NynJa]

<- 0/9 on DM, but I only attempted it twice with a good group, the other 7 times were idiots

"The hume petrified us"
*NIN attempts to solo the mithra on top of the mages*

etc etc

[Nermal]

I was 1/2 on the DM, basically it can be tough if people don't pay attention, that little taru is REALLY evil if you don't kill him fast. Our PLD actually hit Invinciable a half second before the Galka lit him up with a Light Skillchain the last time. I thought the biggest thing is having everone take a Reraiser and Dying in the stinking hallway instead of the middle of the battlefield, I'm pretty sure everyone plans to wipe after you kill 3 of them.

[mdn]

killing DM with 18 blm doesn't exactly qualify your linkshell to list that they've beaten it.

it's easily one of the harder bcs on the game if done with a normal setup

[Nicholas]

From what I hear, this new ouryu bcnm is the hardest now.

[Amarok]

it's easily one of the harder bcs on the game if done with a normal setup

[rooster]

yeah... i talked about ouryu bcnm also in members area...

but we haven't fought, nor have we heard much about it... so it makes it hard to judge, but my guess is it'll be 15-17 points...

18 ppl ... man, everyone has to be perfect.

[Atreides]

what about the new ouryu bcnm? i suppose we should wait for people to actually do it >_>

edit: lol i need to post faster