Originally Posted by
fantasticdan
Go stick it in a dps calculator. With ideal gear/gems in every slot, and under ideal raid conditions (max expose armor, cor, etc.), 63 armor ignore + 1 agility will beat 16 crit rating by under 1 dps. Under much worse conditions, thori'dal will beat golden bow, but by around 2 dps. You would really rather give the bow to a rogue for that, over the 150 minimum dps increase to a hunter that's been raiding sunwell with you for two months? That's really a huge waste of everyones time. You might as well disenchant it and tell your hunters to go fuck themselves.