Knotty Treants, Divine Log?

[VivixKujata]

Do these actually exist or is someone stupid editing wiki to make me go out and farm these?

http://wiki.ffxiclopedia.org/wiki/Knotty_Treant

It says 0%, But on the Leshy (Lufaise Meadows), Rosewood log also says 0%. I have gotten rosewood logs off of Leshy's in lufaise.. But i highly doubt divine logs would come off of a regular monster. >.>

[Apelila]

I wanna say its bullshot but 3 seperate people contributed to that. So I'm guess if it does its <1%, IE not worth your time.

[Waef]

If it dropped Diving Log, RMT would be farming it by now.

[Amele]

it's mirrored over on the divine log table and no editor seems to have questioned it yet (see lack of 'confirmation required' symbol)

yet there's a discussion count of a guy who's 0/312. ofc. there's about a 4% chance of that if the drop rate is 1%. (if the drop rate is say, 1/255 or about .4% it's something like a 30% likelihood of going 0/312)


ever wanted to make a drop that only TH4 thiefs could find?

[Almalexia]

Are you saying I could waltz into the Flamingo page and edit in "Siren's Hair 0/72" on the spot and simply use in my defense "WELL IT HASN'T DROPPED YET, GUYS, SO WE WON'T KNOW FOR SURE UNTIL IT DOES!"

I mean, shit, what's the point of even putting 0/n on a mob drop table aside from screwing with people?

[Amele]

Are you saying I could waltz into the Flamingo page and edit in "Siren's Hair 0/72" on the spot and simply use in my defense "WELL IT HASN'T DROPPED YET, GUYS, SO WE WON'T KNOW FOR SURE UNTIL IT DOES!"

I mean, shit, what's the point of even putting 0/n on a mob drop table aside from screwing with people?

well, presumably someone had a reason to do it and I mean if *something* not an hnm was going to drop one. treants in [s] zones does make the most sense.

it's alot of work to go through for a hoax, and if the suggested drop rate is 'about right' one particular person going 0/312 isn't that unlikely. (I mean shit, I've gone 0/8 on swift belt which is about 4 times less likely.)

edit: I should clarify - I'm not saying it's right that it should say it (on bg-wiki we'd at least have a verification tag on it until someone posted a screenshot of it dropping) but one guy getting 0/312 isn't justification for removing it either. either it's removable because it hasn't been proven - which isn't otherwiki's style (regardless of our personal opinions about whether ffxic is dumb to do it that way or not) - or it's not removable because lack of proof is not proof of negative especially when it's one guy and he's just not even 2 deviations out from normal yet.

[Rama]

The user who added Divine log also added Petrified log to the loot table, which also seems to have a low or null droprate. Both were added on April 27, 2008. It would be interesting to get first-hand comments from him, but I doubt that will happen.

[Calina]

i dont think it does i spent a few days out there on thf messing around killed a few hundred and dident get Dlog yes i have TH4 and still nothing kept count up to 500ish the first day and 2 days after that i did maybe 300ish each

so its ether so rare NOT even a persistent TH4 thf has a chace at it or it dosent drop it prolly just someone messin around laughing at all the ppl he got out there farming for somthing that dosent drop lol

[Therin]

Thanks for your info, but please use periods next time. <_>

[LinktheDeme]

Taisais drop refresh guys we should go farm em.

[Tormentormike]

Mistletoes 25% drop rate my ass!

[Pergo]

a couple days ago i followed this and went to grauberg to farm knotty treants with th3. i killed about 40, got 7 mistletoe and no divine logs... not that that is a big enough sample size to prove anything, but enough to cast some more doubt

[Calina]

Its complete bullshit like i said prolly just some ass laughing while tones of ppl go out and farm it. I took it down off wiki.