Knew I should've mentioned this in my post. Aside from having other distinct advantages (Chapeau's skill, Robe's nuking stats, Dalm's MDB/HP>MP), the difference is you don't pay per tick of MP for these items. Sure, it would take a long time for the cape to add up to the same amount of gil, but the fact that it's a continuous and cumulative payment is what I was getting at. Even if you don't think that's an issue, you can't debate that the inventory space, loss of -PDT% and poison effect aren't a concern.
Seriously all your argument apply to body slot. You don't waste any slot with mog satchel and 80/80 inventory. All you need is 2 extra slots. Get rid of the useless junk in your invo, because there are necessarily highly situational and useless gear in it. Damaged stoneskin ? Oh noes if you care about your pdt you're going to take damage anyway. This just in :
99% of the time Poison tester cape is beneficial for you
Most of the time -7% pdt does nothing for you (cos ugh ... you don't get hit) and there is this nice thing called macro when you are going to get hit.
My normal RDM soloing gear is 79/80. If I get around to getting a cape, I'll certainly be tossing a couple pieces of hmp gear in my mog house and filling my satchel with fruit. Is it an uber piece of gear that you need to be competent? No. Is it always worth using? No. Is it still useful? Yes. You lose two spaces, one for a partial stack of fruit and another for the cape itself.. if you fill up your inventory with all your food you're doing it wrong as is. I only take out toolbags or food when I'm ready to use them. If you carry a seveneyes(1.98% mp saved) and composure refresh/haste/phal every 7.5 min, you're saving 2.5 mp in 10 minutes, or one fourth of a mp per minute. Pretty sure quite a few people carry seveneyes or even fourth mace.. which comparatively gives far far less than half the benefit of a cape + fruit for half the space.
Basically, if you carry seveneyes, fourth mace, or magnetic earring you've invalidated any argument you could make about space.
I don't know about other mages, but for Scholar this sounds pretty decent. Sublimation without Argute Gown or Scholar's Mortarboard is just 2 MP / tick. Ixion Cloak and Poison Taster's Cape would give the same amount without all the hassle of Sublimation. In addition, Ixion Cloak itself will negate the effects of Poison from the fruit. Couple this with Fields of Valor Refresh (Or add Regen for more HP Regen without wasting time for casting Regen,) Sanction, Signet (Blood of the Vampyr) and or Sigil and you have your 3 (or 4) MP / tick without even using Sublimation. For me, it looks much more useful for soloing / duoing. In party situations, its usefulness diminishes. To top if all off, Spellcast can be used to automate the gear swaps when the Poison effect is on without you having to do anything.
Like I said, sounds pretty snazzy for soloing on Scholar at least.
No. What I am saying is that Sublimation, in all it greatness, can be a little bit of a hassle during Soloing because of its indirect nature of giving MP Refresh while sucking away at your HP (which can be a bit of an annoyance if you do not want your Stoneskin damaged by Sublimation poison.) Umbra Cape is still a very good backpiece for soloing but I think it's not as useful in solo's where your not getting hit (I.E Jailer of Fortitude) in which case, P. Taster's Cape would be a slightly better addition.
If it's a nice addition, it's a nice addition regardless of sublimation. There's no reason to ever not use sublimation while soloing..
For the record, nowhere did I state that I don't think people should use it. I said that I'm not sure if it'd be worth the disadvantages associated with it. If they don't apply to you, and you're prepared to deal with the hassle of hauling around fruit, swapping it in and out of your satchel, using a piece every two minutes, etc. etc. then go for it.
You certainly are right. Just need to know how much HP you are getting drained for and adjust your gear accordingly. Sublimation would only interfer with a direct MP Refresh (FoV Refresh.) If you dont have FoV Refresh, then you can Sublimation it up.
A. Sublimation alone | 2 HP / Tick - Ixion's Cloak & Orochi Nodowa (Or FoV Regen.)
B. Sublimation + Fruit | 3 HP / Tick - Ixion's Cloak & Orochi Nodowa & Garden Bangles or FoV Regen.
Add Scholar's Mortarboard or Argute Gown and you have more Poison to deal with. But hence, you are right as it would only interfere with a real Refresh. Like I said, Sublimation is great, having Regen gear (or status) to counter it while soloing makes it even better. Without it, it is a slight annoyance.