Originally Posted by
dem0nfr0g
I have tried feeding a fewell that did not go into the recipe and never received a skillup. We are talking ~ 6 orbs worth of fewell and nothing. While I suppose I could have just been unlucky.. I would wager a guess that to get a skillup, the fewell you feed needs to be used in the recipe. I am about to go on a skillup ramapge and will post if I get a skillup when the element is 99+.
Edit: Just got a skillup on Gold Nugget recipe feeding Earth fewell when it was already @ 99. What I don't know is if it had a chance to leak down to 98 between feedings.