Edit: old post had wrong info.
Edit: old post had wrong info.
Sorry for being lazy and barely skimming the thread, but a quick search for 'charm' came up empty, so I thought I'd share. Did Zh Remnants last night, and the 5th floor frog was particularly spammy. We found that when the entire party was charmed and the frog went back to yellow, even with DoT on, the TH counter would reset. Not sure what the exact trigger for this is, most likely either "mob turns yellow" or "hate is lost", but TH procs are not 100% permanent.
TH was always reset when mobs went passive.
didn't someone do a test with the thf dieing, home pointing, coming back and getting an upgrade ( i.e. the TH didnt reset)? anyway, i was duoing aggressor antlion, and got the TH to 7, got bad luck and wiped. we got up, waiting for weakness ( aggressor was in the area, all passive) reclaimed and the first TH message i got was that it increased to 8. So TH definitely didn't reset on aggressor.
Didnt see this mentioned last time i checked but treasure hound kupopower does stack with TH. was wearing th5 for some job emotes and got a th7 proc on the initial hit.
Fought Tonberry Liege, got TH7 proc, switched from Thief's Knife to Twilight, and got a TH8 proc shortly after.
Looks like we can assume that if you're the same thief, you can hit and upgrade even after you've removed some TH gear.