Page 121 of 139 FirstFirst ... 71 111 119 120 121 122 123 131 ... LastLast
Results 2401 to 2420 of 2776

Thread: FFXIII-2     submit to reddit submit to twitter

  1. #2401
    Bagel
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    1,488
    BG Level
    6

    Quote Originally Posted by Hyan View Post
    The new fans think the new stories are good. The old fans don't.

    But I'd say it's the lack of new fans that's hurting the franchise. It's just old farts that play the games nowadays. There was that one chart where JP's voted which FF was their first one, 7 and 10 came on top, 13 being pretty low. The first FF is the best FF-mindset isn't that surprising considering the nature of these games. Experience an epic tale once and the ones that follow aren't going to be nearly as good in comparison. Especially now when every game tells a story things are different. It's not an RPG exclusive feature any longer.
    The problem here is, almost everyone who is calling FFVII's plot an "epic tale" were like 12 or so when they played it for the first time.
    Now who's more believable? Teens praising their very first JRPG as the best story ever written or 20+ year old people who actually give me educated and reasonable motivations for appreciating the plot of the newer FFs? I'm not saying that everyone is like that, I do give credit to those who have solid arguments to back up their claims of FFVII being the best in the series, but those are not as common as fanboys would like us to believe.

  2. #2402
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    15,501
    BG Level
    9
    FFXIV Character
    Patricia Lanvaldear
    FFXIV Server
    Sargatanas

    You say this as if it is impossible to replay the thing and, you know... still find it to be one of the best.
    That, my friend, is so very wrong.

  3. #2403
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    371
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Titan

    While do people think the "old fans" hate innovation/change? (For the record I don't hate XIII)

    I started playing RPGs when I was 6 years old with Final Fantasy 4 on the SNES in 1991. I grew up with Chrono Trigger (got it the week it was released), Final Fantasy 6, and all the other great SNES/PS1 RPGs! I agree that JRPGs should mix things up a bit, and welcome that. FF 13 went about things the wrong way. The game plays itself practically. "Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway" for damn near 25 hours is not fun. Then at the 25 hour mark your hand is finally let go for a little bit.... Then it's back to "Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway" segments for the remainder of the game. THIS IS NOT FUN! It's an interactive movie. XIII is not a bad game, but to say its not one of the weakest in the series is insanity. The plot was one of the only good things about the game, and it wasn't anything revolutionary. Yes I understood it, it's not that complex. It just requires you to read through the whole DataLog.

    Examples of doing it right: Final Fantasy Tactics, Final Fantasy VIII, Final Fantasy XII... I'll even give you guys X... XIII has a lot of flaws and to try and say people are blinded by nostalgia is hilarious.

    Being innovative: Dark Souls, Skyrim, Bastion, Fallout 3/NV, Nier, etc.

  4. #2404
    I trusted Zet and this is what happened
    Eleven owes me $40 bucks

    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    21,293
    BG Level
    10
    FFXIV Character
    Kaslo Essyx
    FFXIV Server
    Famfrit
    FFXI Server
    Carbuncle

    Quote Originally Posted by Worldshaker View Post
    While do people think the "old fans" hate innovation/change? (For the record I don't hate XIII)

    I started playing RPGs when I was 6 years old with Final Fantasy 4 on the SNES in 1991. I grew up with Chrono Trigger (got it the week it was released), Final Fantasy 6, and all the other great SNES/PS1 RPGs! I agree that JRPGs should mix things up a bit, and welcome that. FF 13 went about things the wrong way. The game plays itself practically. "Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway" for damn near 25 hours is not fun. Then at the 25 hour mark your hand is finally let go for a little bit.... Then it's back to "Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway" segments for the remainder of the game. THIS IS NOT FUN! It's an interactive movie. XIII is not a bad game, but to say its not one of the weakest in the series is insanity. The plot was one of the only good things about the game, and it wasn't anything revolutionary. Yes I understood it, it's not that complex. It just requires you to read through the whole DataLog.

    Examples of doing it right: Final Fantasy Tactics, Final Fantasy VIII, Final Fantasy XII... I'll even give you guys X... XIII has a lot of flaws and to try and say people are blinded by nostalgia is hilarious.

    Being innovative: Dark Souls, Skyrim, Bastion, Fallout 3/NV, Nier, etc.
    To be fair, being one of the disappointments of the series shows how great the series is.

  5. #2405
    CoP Dynamis
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Posts
    274
    BG Level
    4

    Quote Originally Posted by Worldshaker View Post
    XIII has a lot of flaws and to try and say people are blinded by nostalgia is hilarious.
    It's not that people are disliking FFXIII but the way they are expressing it. I hear things like FFXIII is a disgrace to RPGs or RIP FF and RIP SE, etc. Obviously the only response you can give to these is "blinded by nostalgia".

    The problem with that way of expressing is why express it that way? I can see being frustrated or angry (especially if you bought a PS3 just for FFXIII) but it's been nearly two years since release and SE has shown to attempt to fix things.

    Also while FFXIII had a flaws, it had potential to be really good which is something that should be taken into account which many people dismiss or never comment on when disliking FF (the battle system had a lot of potential for example).

    For example, if these were addressed:
    Spoiler: show

    1. The cutscene > hallway > cutscene problem isn't really a problem that they couldn't fix. There are several ways around it (even with the story) such as using save stations as a hub for mini games and side quests. One example is a Save Station could also act as a way teleport to a town. The group somehow obtains an ability to disguise themselves.

    Instead of multiple towns, they could do one big town with mini games, side quests, monster arena, etc.

    Also the game being a "movie" is kind of standard for most FF games. Most FF had a ton of dialogue and scenes. IMO I think the problem is lack of customization options and battle system being boring at times.

    (A comparison) In a sense, FFT had no towns (it's just a menu) or no exploration (okay it did near the end of the game but so did FFXIII!!!1). It was kind of linear too (exploration and storywise). Most of the gameplay came from grinding.

    If FFXIII had better gameplay, then I'm sure people would have been okay with it being linear (at least how you move from place to place).

    2. Battle system. One major complaint is that the fights get more and more tedious later on (and you can't outgrind it). Regular fights could last 1-3 minutes on average + they don't give crazy rewards or loot (ooo I got CP which I already capped and 50 gil worth of items! Woot!). This is unlike other FFs where after a long fight, you're usually at least rewarded (not counting FF8).

    This actually diminishes one of the biggest appeals of RPGs - The reward for grinding. In FFXIII, the grind:reward ratio is really low compared to other FF games (well except maybe FFXII which was grindy as well if you didn't know what to do).

    Also the game needed more customization options (just unlock all roles from the beginning, add the ability to upgrade abilities, etc), harder boss fights and easier regular fights. Since the battle system doesn't affect the story or anything, a lot could have been improved or changed.

    3. Some story things need to be explained better.... unless they're intentionally saving it for a sequel or so.

    FFXIII had flaws but it had much potential to be good. I would like people to at least acknowledging what had potential or at least stating what SE could have fixed (SE does read stuff apparently; maybe official game reviews at least) but the problem is most people just hate on FF without saying how SE could have improved it the way it was made.

    I occasionally see people who dislike FFXIII at least acknowledged that what was done had potential (the battle system) but most of the time I hear the same "FFXIII is bad" or "RIP FF series"/"RIP Square" one line comments over and over. That's what prompts the whole "blinded by nostalgia" comments from people who like FFXIII (which I admit to doing myself previously in another thread).

    (Though I'll claim "blinded by nostalgia" to anyone who doesn't like the music in FFXIII.)

    tl;dr + conclusion: "blinded by nostalgia" because of 1-line "FFXIII is bad" or "Square is dead" comments without acknowledging potential or what was done right. Also FFT had no towns too (in a sense) (see in spoiler tag).

    but to say its not one of the weakest in the series is insanity. The plot was one of the only good things about the game, and it wasn't anything revolutionary. Yes I understood it, it's not that complex. It just requires you to read through the whole DataLog.
    I disagree unless you're only talking about the gameplay/battle system itself, which was really close to being great (main problem was the lack of customization, bad grind:reward ratio, and boss battles being too easy). IMO, the only weak parts of FFXIII were the three major things I discussed in the spoiler tags and those weren't too bad.

    (Actually nvm, I'll just post it here in spoiler tags)
    Spoiler: show
    FFXIII had a horrible grind:reward ratio compared to nearly every other FF game (except FF8 unless you count playing cards as grinding, and FF12; I'd even say FF11 had a better sense of reward with grinding than FF13 and FF12).

    That's one of the huge appeals of RPGs.

    In FF13 there wasn't much of that due to the cap of crystranium, no gil drops, and the fact that the loot dropped was almost negligible for the most part (with the exception of turtles and some marks).

    So I don't think that lack of towns or "the game is linear" is the problem (again, technically FFT had no towns, an barely had much exploration until near the end) but the battle system (and its lack of customization) and there being little incentive to grind.

    That's why grind MMOs still get played. There's an incentive (regardless of how boring the battle system may be to some). FFXIII doesn't have that and it needed it (also customization options too).

    FFXII too actually (1% drop rate with armor that isn't even that much better than the current armor you can buy; same with most weapons too). A lot of the times I didn't really feel like grinding. In FFXI there was so much fun stuff that can be gained from grinding and the loot was good too.

    Basically tl;dr:

    More customization options and more rewards from battle. Harder bosses. Now the game is liked by all (no need for towns or open fields).

  6. #2406
    Yoshi P
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    5,092
    BG Level
    8

    Quote Originally Posted by Worldshaker View Post
    While do people think the "old fans" hate innovation/change? (For the record I don't hate XIII)

    I started playing RPGs when I was 6 years old with Final Fantasy 4 on the SNES in 1991. I grew up with Chrono Trigger (got it the week it was released), Final Fantasy 6, and all the other great SNES/PS1 RPGs! I agree that JRPGs should mix things up a bit, and welcome that. FF 13 went about things the wrong way. The game plays itself practically. "Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway" for damn near 25 hours is not fun. Then at the 25 hour mark your hand is finally let go for a little bit.... Then it's back to "Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway --> Cutscene --> Hallway" segments for the remainder of the game. THIS IS NOT FUN! It's an interactive movie. XIII is not a bad game, but to say its not one of the weakest in the series is insanity. The plot was one of the only good things about the game, and it wasn't anything revolutionary. Yes I understood it, it's not that complex. It just requires you to read through the whole DataLog.

    Examples of doing it right: Final Fantasy Tactics, Final Fantasy VIII, Final Fantasy XII... I'll even give you guys X... XIII has a lot of flaws and to try and say people are blinded by nostalgia is hilarious.

    Being innovative: Dark Souls, Skyrim, Bastion, Fallout 3/NV, Nier, etc.
    Behesta games just make me cringe. I despise Fallout with every ounce of my existence. If FF games became anything like those I would've quit playing them long time ago.
    Also, as good as Dark Souls is, it's Demons Souls 2. Improved a bit, but it's nothing new.

  7. #2407
    New Odin
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    8,825
    BG Level
    8

    Skyrim innovative? Dear God it's like FFVII all over again.

    Overrated PoS, that game.

    But what Skyrim does and you don't want FF to do is to focus on it's strengths. Open world is that game's strength- it rules above all, even the shitty gameplay.

    FF's strength is not open world. "Hallway > cutscene > hallway > cutscene" or "two hallways > cutscene > empty open world with one place to go to advance the story > cutscene" is not any different. It's not any more "playing a game" unless having to run around with no purpose but to stretch the game out is considered "playing a game".

    Then again, when other games do this it's suddenly fine. MGS? DMC? You can say the same fucking thing about these games. "But they're different" fuck you they aren't. The only difference is that during the PSX era the pipe you ran through was wider, yet still had as little substance. Action games know what the fuck and don't even bother with that crap.

    Maybe it had some grandeur back then? Now you have dedicated open world games that strip you out of any grandeur. SE can't compete when they also have a linear story-based scenario to tell. This is obvious.

  8. #2408
    Yoshi P
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    5,092
    BG Level
    8

    Quote Originally Posted by Hyan View Post
    Skyrim innovative? Dear God it's like FFVII all over again.

    Overrated PoS, that game.
    Skyrim is like the Beatles, even the games that were designed before Skyrim stole ideas from Skyrim

  9. #2409
    New Odin
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    8,825
    BG Level
    8

    And if XII was so good maybe people should stop bitching about it like the whiners they are. I liked XII too, but that didn't stop the bawhaw's from happening. How should SE take that message given to them by the fans?

  10. #2410
    Black Belt
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    5,907
    BG Level
    8
    FFXI Server
    Quetzalcoatl

    Quote Originally Posted by Hyan View Post
    Skyrim innovative? Dear God it's like FFVII all over again.

    Overrated PoS, that game.

    But what Skyrim does and you don't want FF to do is to focus on it's strengths. Open world is that game's strength- it rules above all, even the shitty gameplay.

    FF's strength is not open world. "Hallway > cutscene > hallway > cutscene" or "two hallways > cutscene > empty open world with one place to go to advance the story > cutscene" is not any different. It's not any more "playing a game" unless having to run around with no purpose but to stretch the game out is considered "playing a game".

    Then again, when other games do this it's suddenly fine. MGS? DMC? You can say the same fucking thing about these games. "But they're different" fuck you they aren't. The only difference is that during the PSX era the pipe you ran through was wider, yet still had as little substance. Action games know what the fuck and don't even bother with that crap.

    Maybe it had some grandeur back then? Now you have dedicated open world games that strip you out of any grandeur. SE can't compete when they also have a linear story-based scenario to tell. This is obvious.
    Or baynetta. Was more linear than XIII, but is still loved by everyone.

  11. #2411
    New Odin
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    8,825
    BG Level
    8

    Quote Originally Posted by Uzor View Post
    Or baynetta. Was more linear than XIII, but is still loved by everyone.
    Due to it's gameplay though. XIII can't compete with it but it can still be as entertaining unless the quality of gameplay/challenge is the most decisive factor for your enjoyment of a game. For most people who like this franchise, I don't think that is too important. Even XIII was too challenging for some. I'd say it still comes down to non-gamey factors that is the dealbreaker for this franchise. The earlier entries practically demanded nothing but time of the player, but not many gave a shit.

  12. #2412
    The Defense is ready, Your Honor
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    20,642
    BG Level
    10
    FFXIV Character
    Lord Longhaft
    FFXIV Server
    Gilgamesh
    FFXI Server
    Cerberus
    WoW Realm
    Mug'thol

    I miss my 5-man party from FFIV. I always felt that a 5-man allowed every party member to be unique, instead of the "everyone can be every-THING" that we've really gotten since those days. Granted, everyone could have been everything in FFIII as well, but I digress.

  13. #2413
    Black Belt
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    5,907
    BG Level
    8
    FFXI Server
    Quetzalcoatl

    I liked FFIX's "4-party" system. It also gave each character a unique feel.

    Honestly; IX is probably my favorite in the "modern" Final Fantasies. It's the only one I've completed more than three times. I actually haven't even completed FFVIII... I've tried to complete it three times, but I always grow bored of it. One day I will just bite the apple and go through the last dungeon...

  14. #2414
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    371
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Titan

    Of course every FF is linear. Most RPGs have one route leading to the end of the game.

    FFXIII simply lacked optional content in between the Hallway > Cutscene > Hallway > Cutscene segments. This is why people claim the older FFs are less linear. World maps just give the illusion of freedom, which is all most people are asking for. Giving players optional places to run around and explore is FUN. Finding secret towns/dungeons on the world map was a blast. They could accomplish all of this without a world map (Like FFXII did).

    It all comes down to is choices. Having the option to over level yourself, go to endgame places early in the adventure, being able to backtrack at will to old dungeons/villages. Having NPCs to talk to for additional information about the world. Having mini games to play when you don't feel like progressing with the story. Casinos are fun. Chocobo Racing is fun. Snowboarding mini games are fun. Collecting rare drops can be fun. Having optional super bosses is fun. Raising monsters to fight against each other is fun..... Being forced to run down hallways for 50 hours is not.

    They do not have to copy any of the previous mini games by any means. Create new ways to have fun outside of the main adventure. RPGs have always been about exploration, and freedom in combination with a strong story. RPGs should not try to become Action games completely, but instead look at what they do right and try to borrow some ideas to spice things up.

    FFXIII had a lot of potential, and I think Square has a good base to work with. The best Final Fantasy could be on the horizon for sure. They have what it takes to make phenomenal games.

    Also, as good as Dark Souls is, it's Demons Souls 2. Improved a bit, but it's nothing new.
    I just chose Dark Souls because IMO it is the better of the two. It was an example of a new series doing it right. Innovation done right this gen.

    Skyrim innovative? Dear God it's like FFVII all over again.

    Overrated PoS, that game.
    I agree Skyrim is overrated, but its hardly a PoS. Its a great game that did a lot right. The level up system, character customization, freedom it gave you (guilds, housing, optional content), and open world experience is something no other game to this date has done on such a massive level.

    I have played the game as a Mage, Berserker, Archer/Thief, and even dabbled in hybrid builds all of which have been rewarding and fun.

    I don't know how anyone could rationally think FFXIIIs gameplay is above Skyrims. FFXIII held your throughout the entire game (minus 5 starring the Hunt missions)

  15. #2415
    New Odin
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    8,825
    BG Level
    8

    It all comes down to is choices.
    And choices like you mentioned come down to shitty balance. You will see this with XIII-2 which is considerably easier than it's predecessor.

    I don't know how anyone could rationally think FFXIIIs gameplay is above Skyrims. FFXIII held your throughout the entire game (minus 5 starring the Hunt missions)
    FFXIII was actually difficult once it opened up fully (because it kept your progression in check). Skyrim's "difficulty" came down to stats and stats only (also fighting against the shitty UI). Plus with all the ways you could make yourself overpowered I would be amazed if somebody didn't manage to break the game after the first twenty hours. The freedom the game gives you makes the actual gameplay a pile of horse shit.

    While it is not what makes the game appealing, even the thought of Skyrim's gameplay being above anything is hilarious. They are practically stuck in the 90's.

  16. #2416
    Bagel
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    1,488
    BG Level
    6

    Quote Originally Posted by Worldshaker View Post

    I don't know how anyone could rationally think FFXIIIs gameplay is above Skyrims.
    I find FFXIII's battles to be far more enjoyable than Skyrim's incredibly simplicistic combat. Sure, Skyrim has a lot of farming/crafting/character customization, but it's hardly new and exciting content for those who have played at least a MMORPG before. And most users on this forums have.
    I'll give the nod to Skyrim on the exploration and immersion part, but I can't say that I've found the game as a whole to be more fun than FFXIII.

    FFXIII held your throughout the entire game (minus 5 starring the Hunt missions)
    What exactly is your definition of "hand holding"? Tutorial fights when a new skill is introduced? There's nothing wrong with it.
    Or do you mean low difficulty?
    I have gotten far more game overs in FFXIII than the other FFs combined, and not because of the whole "leader dies = game over" thing. More often than not, my leader was always the one who died last.

  17. #2417
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    371
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Titan

    I honestly had no trouble with XIII, I don't see how some on this board think it's so challenging. I've only had a few Game Overs, and those were mostly to me getting greedy and letting Lightning get low on some of the more challenging fights.

    Hell people have beaten the game without using Crystarium at all (Just weapon/accessory upgrades). I've played through Skyrim on Master difficulty, and have found that MUCH more challenging personally. Playing on Master as a Mage is so much fun. Even if you powerlevel blacksmithing, alchemy, and enchanting its still loads of fun.

    I'll give the nod to Skyrim on the exploration and immersion part, but I can't say that I've found the game as a whole to be more fun than FFXIII.
    I was just speaking in terms of gameplay. Skyrim has so much more going on compared to XIII. It's just an interactive movie with an interesting battle system. I do find XIII a lot of fun, and am not trying to say Skyrim is a more fun game to play (thats up to the individual to decide).

    @Hyan - Yeah you're right, stuck in the 90's

  18. #2418
    New Odin
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    8,825
    BG Level
    8

    I honestly had no trouble with XIII, I don't see how some on this board think it's so challenging.
    It's more challenging than Skyrim for the right reasons (hint: "you didn't grind enough" is not one).

    Of course at the end of the day we're comparing which poop smells the least, but whatever.

    Hell people have beaten the game without using Crystarium at all (Just weapon/accessory upgrades). I've played through Skyrim on Master difficulty, and have found that MUCH more challenging personally. Playing on Master as a Mage is so much fun. Even if you powerlevel blacksmithing, alchemy, and enchanting its still loads of fun.
    One shotting is indeed fun for the first 5 minutes. Then your stats might be a little low so it's time to grind grind grind until the numbers are on your side again! That's challenge for ya.

    @Hyan - Yeah you're right, stuck in the 90's
    Crap. Morrowind came out in the 2000's? My bad.

  19. #2419
    New Spam Forum
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    176
    BG Level
    3
    FFXI Server
    Gilgamesh

    Quote Originally Posted by Nevex View Post
    I find FFXIII's battles to be far more enjoyable than Skyrim's incredibly simplicistic combat. Sure, Skyrim has a lot of farming/crafting/character customization, but it's hardly new and exciting content for those who have played at least a MMORPG before.
    That's one of the reasons i find Skyrim so enjoyable. It's simple. When i play an RPG i want to feel involved and immersed in the battles and for me Skyrim does that. 13 never really grabbed my in the same way. Bosses are a hell of a lot of fun mind.

    I have to agree with the linearness of 13s gameplay though. With some more custimisation, mini-games etc it would definately of relieved some of the tediouness of it. Really hope they don't use another leveling cap in FF13-2. Love nothing more when playing any FFs to find a nice spot and grind a good few levels out, like in FF12 for example. Once you hit the cap you were forced to continue with the main quest.

  20. #2420
    Ridill
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    12,876
    BG Level
    9
    FFXIV Character
    Teisha Linne
    FFXIV Server
    Moogle
    FFXI Server
    Bahamut

    There's no cap in XIII-2

Page 121 of 139 FirstFirst ... 71 111 119 120 121 122 123 131 ... LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. FFXIII Anouncment Trailer now on PSN
    By Faxanadu in forum Square-Enix Titles
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 2009-02-01, 10:53
  2. New FFXIII & Versus Vids. ?
    By SephYuyX in forum Square-Enix Titles
    Replies: 155
    Last Post: 2009-01-12, 14:17
  3. New FFXIII Trailers
    By Natallon in forum Square-Enix Titles
    Replies: 135
    Last Post: 2008-08-21, 14:41
  4. FFXIII on 360
    By SephYuyX in forum Square-Enix Titles
    Replies: 83
    Last Post: 2008-07-22, 17:21
  5. New Pictures from FFXIII
    By Kimiko in forum Square-Enix Titles
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 2008-01-25, 21:56