
Originally Posted by
Zounder
Not to really get into an argument, but draft position doesn't matter when evaluating a trade, even before the season starts. If I drafted Matt Ryan in the first round, is it OK for me to trade him for Ray Rice, because they were both valued as first round talents by the players in the league? Honestly, I think Turner/Amendola for Ryan/Gore is pretty unbalanced, but not enough for a veto. I am of the belief vetoes should only happen in drastically unbalanced trades. I think Turner is the slightly better RB (not by much) and Ryan should definitely have more value than Amendola, making the trade in favor of the person getting Gore/Ryan, but it's not completely crazy.
From what I understand, the person giving up Ryan has him as his backup. That might be his reason for letting himself get ripped off a bit-- he doesn't lose his starting QB, so the trade to him boils down to what he feels is an upgrade and RB and a free WR. (Not that Id do that trade)