
Originally Posted by
EternityEnd
Exactly. You live in California—Hollywood, for fuck's sake—the capital of the vocal minority of which we speak, because the "community" there engenders the idea that gay people should act a certain way (though it is not intrinsic). In the rest of the world, however, things are quite different for the majority. California is an outlier.
You're trying to impose California's communal indoctrination on to your perception of the rest of the world. In essence, comparing the traditional quirks focused in a single region on everyone else. It's ludicrous. I would wager, however, that most gay people there are still "normal," you're just falling prey to the exact same fallacious assumption that I outlined in my first post. You assume all of the normal people you meet are straight—by default—erroneously drawing the conclusion that, therefore, they are all straight, and that stereotypically gay people are the majority, because they're the most obvious. That's what a vocal minority is.
The truth of what I present is patently obvious if one but bestirs themselves for one moment to look at the entire world and its history. America, and to a lesser prevalence, Canada and the United Kingdom, are the only countries with any sort of notable effeminate behavior. That's because the media in those countries posits the notion that gay people act effeminately, implicating to gay people growing up that they should conform to that idea in order to gain a sense of community—belonging. This is caused by both decades-old prejudice as well as the media's inherent proclivity to simplify things, rather than inform. It's, in my opinion, a tragic loss of individualism. If you deign to look anywhere else, though—particularly the impoverished regions of the world, with a lack of media—you'll see that people share no such mannerisms. At all. People are inclined to adopt whatever artificialities their culture imposes on the group with whom they identify. Basically, traditional behavior is self-perpetuating. That doesn't make it at all intrinsic.
Your "broad spectrum" of experience is deplorably narrow; if you'd care enough to open your eyes, you might realize.