Note: Vulcan's Staff, Rose Strap and Armageddon in all cases.
Outside of Voidwatch (Coercion), these are the STP amounts I need to 4hit armageddon with Misers Roll:
VIII (13) - 38STP
IX (15) - 34STP
X (17) - 31STP
V (20) - 25STP
XI (25) - 14STP
The max I can get without /sam appears to be 36 (Rose Strap, Houyi, Volley, Loki's, Hoard, Rajas, Oneiros, AF3+2 legs). I could farm the Praeda hands/feet for STP+5 also.
The question is, at what point do the TP phase gains from 5hitting outweigh 4hitting? Or don't they? Assuming the Af3 hand/rancor/loki setup mentioned above is best damage,
To 4hit the VIII Misers, I'd need:
AF3+2/Rancor/Clearview/Volley
Loki's/Praeda/Horde/Rajas
AF3/Oneiros/AF3+2/Praeda
I basically lose 36~ Racc and 5% Crit in exchange for 19~ Ratt and dropping from 5>4 hit. This is non-coercion at the moment, so outside voidwatch. At 99, I shouldn't be needing that 30-odd racc outside voidwatch I'm guessing. If that's worthwhile, then all the other misers roll tiers will be as well, as they'll all be trading off STP for damage stats.
Enter voidwatch, and these are STP requiements for 3hit.
VIII (33) - 47STP
IX (35) - 41STP
X (37) - 35STP
V (40) - 26STP
XI (45) - 11STP
It's impossible to 3hit on a VIII, however I can 3hit a IX roll with:
AF3+2/Hyoui/Clearview/Volley
Loki's/Praeda/Horde/Rajas
AF3/Oneiros/AF3+2/Praeda
This loses 10% Crit and about 36~ Acc. However, this is voidwatch, where Racc will actually matter. I was using Sushi and had confidently capped Racc against Jeuno T3-5 and Zilart T3, but knowing it was likely overkill, I'd also be interested in changing to Pot-Au-Feu or RCBs when I can.
I'm unconvinced in that losing all that racc and crit would pull ahead in voidwatch, especially if I stop eating sushi. Thoughts?
For X roll, the set is essentially the same except I can swap out the Praeda Set for AF3+2 hands/feet for +10~ Racc and +5Crit, but losing 10ratt, or Oneiros/Houyi > Rancor/Impulse for +5Racc +3Snapshot +5Crit, but losing 9ratt
Similar question - in voidwatch, do you think it's worth it? Still losing 26-31~ Racc on 5% Crit.
For V roll, 26STP is much more reasonable. Rose, Loki's, Volley, Rajas and AF3+2 legs do this. The set isn't dissimilar from the set I was talking about at start of post. I'm confident this is worth it. XI roll 3hits naturally with just rose strap and AF3+2 legs, but it's impossible to 2hit it.
I can fudge around my QD set, and make multiple versions as well. Can always use Schultzen to help with some of the higher STP requirement times.