
Originally Posted by
Byrthnoth
pchan was banned for starting fights. rog was banned for starting fights. Neosutra was banned for arguing with someone in every thread, but I forget who. Thorny was banned for starting fights. Fights go on for pages (and increase post counts) but don't generate any new information or really help anyone.
* I'd be the first to admit that pchan was willing to collect/analyze data and played a useful role in the community, but testing threads are much less derogatory and more approachable for new people without him around. There's no guy with 5,000 posts swooping in and threatening the health of your mother because you didn't get a sufficient sample size on your first outing anymore.
* I can count the pieces of novel information that rog contributed on one hand without using many fingers. His knowledge of the game was encyclopedic, but he himself did not generate new information. We've lost a little response time in RQT with him gone, but that's it.
* When Neosutra entered threads and argued about random crap, I'd just stop reading because I knew the thread was essentially dead. I can't say for sure if he ever tested stuff or not. I know that he has recently tested things on FFXIAH and is contributing to the Paladin community nicely.
* Thorny tested things and contributed strategies for endgame events as they were released, or optimized old strategies, but he was just too caustic for the community at this point. Last I heard he quit everything FFXI-related anyway.
I wasn't honestly happy to see any of these posters go. I didn't tend to end up arguing with any of them and knew how not to step on their toes. Still, all the negative stereotypes about BG that you see propagated through other boards are due to posters exactly like this. I'm not saying everyone who comes here looking for information is going to fit in, but we can gently show them the door instead of throwing them outside and then curb stomping them.
It used to be that asking misguided questions in RQT would get you verbally decimated by someone. Now people either just ignore it or try to redirect your question to something more defined so that they can answer it.