
Originally Posted by
Renzokuken
Love the discussion that's going on in here.
It seems like the consensus is that casual and hardcore gamers can't co-exist in an MMO together long term. As far as current MMO designs, this is almost certainly true. As many have stated, developers/publishers seem to be using the "largest net" philosophy, which ends up disappointing both target groups.
However, I see no reason, in the future, that developers can't cater to both groups. Other posters have stated that these two groups are at odds, but how true is that really?
I would define casuals as players that play on their own terms and for the most part don't care to compare themselves to the rest of the player base. Either they restrict their playtime or they choose to not experience the full content of the game for whatever reason. By contrast, the hardcore crowd is focused on maximization. They are often out to be the best, which means doing the most rewarding content and often translating to many more hours in game over casuals.
These two philosophies are not at odds. Hardcore players will probably not want to do events with casuals because they will never be the "best" players, and casuals tend to dislike the hardcore crowd because of the "elitist" comments that I've often seen leading to silly arguments in game and on forums. Other than these abrasive tenancies, both groups can co-exist if the developer is willing and able to provide content for both.
It seems that everyone knows both groups exist, but publishers aren't willing to cater to both groups in the same game. I hope this is something that is able to change, because in MMO's the more people playing, the more fun for everyone imo.
P.S. Fuck the current single player mentality that seems to persist in all recent MMO's.