Page 27 of 52 FirstFirst ... 17 25 26 27 28 29 37 ... LastLast
Results 521 to 540 of 1026
  1. #521
    Sandworm Swallows
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    7,328
    BG Level
    8

    As an additional thought on catering to the hardcore: While catering to casuals attracts more players, catering to hardcores attracts fewer but more dedicated players. There has to be a successful revenue model based on long-term profitability rather than the quick cash grab out there somewhere.

    When developers start targeting the focus of their MMO to a type of gamer, then the genre might make a come back. It is also easier to give players what they want when you have a more unified and focused group, instead of just trying to give everyone everything.

  2. #522
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Posts
    616
    BG Level
    5

    Quote Originally Posted by Alderaan View Post
    LOTRO's game world
    GW2's combat and dynamic event system
    FFXI's class system - 1 character for every class (this also supports getting to know people instead of alts)
    WoW/Rift raiding
    SWG's crafting
    GW2's PVP - seriously, enough splitting the server into 2 factions (also supports server pride)
    FFXI's alt raiding -multiple routes for gear (minus the crappy itemization of course)
    Alternate elite areas for people to group grind in
    Eliminate low drop rates and instead make content difficult

    Genre fixed!
    I'd change that with EVE Online's PVP. 1 world, 1 server. Your actions have consequences and you can't just run and hide on another server.

  3. #523
    Relic Horn
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    3,485
    BG Level
    7
    FFXI Server
    Shiva
    WoW Realm
    Stormrage

    I don't think the EVE formula would work with fantasy. You'd have far too many players than the server could handle with more taxing graphics. If it were possible, it would be amazing and quite annoying at the same time.

  4. #524
    A. Body
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Posts
    4,315
    BG Level
    7
    FFXI Server
    Leviathan

    Quote Originally Posted by ringthree View Post
    As an additional thought on catering to the hardcore: While catering to casuals attracts more players, catering to hardcores attracts fewer but more dedicated players. There has to be a successful revenue model based on long-term profitability rather than the quick cash grab out there somewhere.

    When developers start targeting the focus of their MMO to a type of gamer, then the genre might make a come back. It is also easier to give players what they want when you have a more unified and focused group, instead of just trying to give everyone everything.

    While true to a point, wouldn't that also make the generally false assumption that the dedication of a playerbase is static?

    Assuming that, the problem with targeted focus is that fluctuating interest just points players elsewhere. If you want someone playing your game for, say, a decade, then you need to account for that customer likely representing both the casual and hardcore segments at different points in that timeframe. Something with broad appeal can succeed in keeping their business where an overly focused product bleeds subscriptions.

    Another possible issue is that the more people are exposed to the genre, the more general recognition there is for the ulterior motives of the genre. Simply put, MMOs compromise their design as games in order to hook players and maintain cashflow. More people are likely to be guarded, if not bitter regarding MMOs, and thus less likely to play them, much less play them hardcore.
    I think greater success will come when games stop trying to be WoW, and instead figure out how to appeal to the millions of players who won't touch WoW.

  5. #525
    Eli Manning is my Lord and Savior
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    6,097
    BG Level
    8
    FFXI Server
    Cerberus
    WoW Realm
    Greymane

    Quote Originally Posted by Zerocool View Post
    I have no delusions of somebody ever making a game like FFXI again, nor would I play it if they did. Like I said in previous posts, the forced grouping just to level and grinding mobs I could never do again. My point was that devs need to step away from the raid only grind end game model and start doing something like FFXI did and provide varied end-game activities for people to play. Yeah, FFXI was never as popular as WoW, but neither was any game that game after WoW that tried to copy it's model. And if you look at all those WoW clones now they've pretty much all gone F2P/are about to or have shut down. While FFXI is still running off of subscriptions. Sure it's a small niche crowd, but it's probably still turning a profit. I don't think that WoW's end game model is popular, I think that WoW is popular and people aren't going to leave it to play something exactly the same when they've already put so much time into WoW.
    Pretty much this, while FF11 had ALOT of good things going for it, there was alot wrong wtih it but people stuck around cause A) was an early console MMO and B) not alot of choices back then and C) it was called Final Fantasy. But now if someone is gonna look for features to include in a new MMO, even with FF11 being as popular as it was in its day before and even after WoW release(was still a Top 5 after that), everyone would rather try and copy WoW mechanics because WoW has been the most popular MMO to date.

    I think the major issue here is that people expect WoW or even half WoW-like success. This is a terrible mentality. Before WoW came out, if you had 100k subs as an MMO you were VERY successful. People see the retardedly high number that WoW attracted for several reasons, and believe they can try and get some of that market. No MMO has really come close to those numbers, and the P2P ones that survive to this day do so because of their very niche communities(FF11, Eve, RO until recently, etc). I've played alot of WoW, I enjoyed the game. But I'm not really interested in trying any of the WoW clones that came out because for that I can just go back to playing WoW where I know it'll keep going and have continued support while the clone becomes forgotten like Vanguard, Age of Conan, etc.

  6. #526
    Relic Horn
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    3,411
    BG Level
    7
    FFXIV Character
    Purrrfect Lee
    FFXIV Server
    Hyperion
    FFXI Server
    Cerberus

    Quote Originally Posted by Lucavi View Post
    Why aren't you still playing XI if it is the be-all-end-all of MMOs throughout history (IE: your first true MMO experience)? Yes, the modern MMOs follow the same script, but if XI's design was so good, why wasn't it successfully copied?
    Abyssea. And to an extremely lesser extent ToAU, though it's pluses outweighed it's minuses. Instead of other MMOs copying XI, XI started copying other MMOs to appeal to their crowd. I imagine it was a good decisions for the life of the game, it's just not a game I like anymore. /minority

  7. #527
    New Spam Forum
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    189
    BG Level
    3
    FFXI Server
    Valefor

    Love the discussion that's going on in here.

    It seems like the consensus is that casual and hardcore gamers can't co-exist in an MMO together long term. As far as current MMO designs, this is almost certainly true. As many have stated, developers/publishers seem to be using the "largest net" philosophy, which ends up disappointing both target groups.

    However, I see no reason, in the future, that developers can't cater to both groups. Other posters have stated that these two groups are at odds, but how true is that really?

    I would define casuals as players that play on their own terms and for the most part don't care to compare themselves to the rest of the player base. Either they restrict their playtime or they choose to not experience the full content of the game for whatever reason. By contrast, the hardcore crowd is focused on maximization. They are often out to be the best, which means doing the most rewarding content and often translating to many more hours in game over casuals.

    These two philosophies are not at odds. Hardcore players will probably not want to do events with casuals because they will never be the "best" players, and casuals tend to dislike the hardcore crowd because of the "elitist" comments that I've often seen leading to silly arguments in game and on forums. Other than these abrasive tenancies, both groups can co-exist if the developer is willing and able to provide content for both.

    It seems that everyone knows both groups exist, but publishers aren't willing to cater to both groups in the same game. I hope this is something that is able to change, because in MMO's the more people playing, the more fun for everyone imo.

    P.S. Fuck the current single player mentality that seems to persist in all recent MMO's.

  8. #528
    Relic Horn
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    3,485
    BG Level
    7
    FFXI Server
    Shiva
    WoW Realm
    Stormrage

    Quote Originally Posted by Renzokuken View Post
    Love the discussion that's going on in here.

    It seems like the consensus is that casual and hardcore gamers can't co-exist in an MMO together long term. As far as current MMO designs, this is almost certainly true. As many have stated, developers/publishers seem to be using the "largest net" philosophy, which ends up disappointing both target groups.

    However, I see no reason, in the future, that developers can't cater to both groups. Other posters have stated that these two groups are at odds, but how true is that really?

    I would define casuals as players that play on their own terms and for the most part don't care to compare themselves to the rest of the player base. Either they restrict their playtime or they choose to not experience the full content of the game for whatever reason. By contrast, the hardcore crowd is focused on maximization. They are often out to be the best, which means doing the most rewarding content and often translating to many more hours in game over casuals.

    These two philosophies are not at odds. Hardcore players will probably not want to do events with casuals because they will never be the "best" players, and casuals tend to dislike the hardcore crowd because of the "elitist" comments that I've often seen leading to silly arguments in game and on forums. Other than these abrasive tenancies, both groups can co-exist if the developer is willing and able to provide content for both.

    It seems that everyone knows both groups exist, but publishers aren't willing to cater to both groups in the same game. I hope this is something that is able to change, because in MMO's the more people playing, the more fun for everyone imo.

    P.S. Fuck the current single player mentality that seems to persist in all recent MMO's.
    The problem is rewards. Hardcore don't like seeing casuals in the same gear as them as it devalues their "hard work". At the same time, many casuals want the same top end gear without having to be hardcore.

    You might be thinking hey they're casuals, they don't expect the same gear, but that seems to be untrue. I've lost track of how many threads i've seen on other forums of games that have people saying they're entitled to the same chance at gear but don't want to do the same content as the hardcore. It's like people that want raiding gear because it's the best but don't want to actually raid? Why the need for the gear? It's because people are stupid and they don't know what they want, they just know they want it now. Why would a casual start a new MMO knowing they can never achieve top end gear when they can just keep playing one that allows them to?

    I don't think they can coexist until both parties can agree on what's fair big picture wise. We're not anywhere near that happening.

  9. #529
    The Defense is ready, Your Honor
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    20,642
    BG Level
    10
    FFXIV Character
    Lord Longhaft
    FFXIV Server
    Gilgamesh
    FFXI Server
    Cerberus
    WoW Realm
    Mug'thol

    I think the value of gear itself has to come into equation, then. You have hardcores that are so hardcore that they're willing to cheat to be the best, and are willing to keep others from obtaining the same gear that they have if the rules (or lack of proper rules, in the case of XI) allow it. You have hardcores that don't care who obtains the gear, so long as they work for it. You have casuals who want the best gear, but aren't willing to work for it. You have casuals who don't care about the best gear, and just want to be able to see the content at some point.

    MMOs in general have been terrible at making everyone happy. The old days of WoW were lucky to have 2% of the playerbase seeing the top-end of content, which kind of pissed the devs off, as they felt that all of that work was for nothing. I remember Blizz saying something around 2.7% of players saw Magister's Terrace in TBC. That's terrible for a game that has/had so many subs, so I can easily see how/why they changed things for Wotlk, which wound up pissing off a minority, but allowed for a majority to experience the content. Experiencing the content and clearing the content are two different things, however, and most people didn't beat the Lich King, which is fine and dandy, so long as they saw him once or twice.

    XI was just... all over the place. You had unbeatable monsters that were broken to all hell to the point where people had to cheat and exploit to win, you had stupid easy monsters that dropped top-tier gear at low percentages that people would fight over, you had systems that required multiple alliances of different linkshells to cooperate for piss-poor droprates, you had systems designed to essentially promote botting... and then you had Limbus; a pretty well balanced, fairly interesting system that gave good rewards for solid effort. Yet all of these systems had their hardcore fans and hardcore haters. Some people thought the bosses should be invincible. Some people loved the grind and the rarity of legit salvage drops. Some people loved the exclusivity of Ein drops. Some people hated the "ease" of completion and of gear dropping in limbus.

    When even the hardcores can't agree on systems, how do you expect companies to address the differences between hardcores and casuals? They can't, so they don't.

  10. #530
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    584
    BG Level
    5

    I think GW2 has the best chance at having hardcore and casual players coexist in the same game. The game is extremely accessible in that anybody can just jump in and start playing. Casuals can just jump into PvE, run around and do events, play story mode dungeons, participate in the big dynamic event boss fights. They can also just right into structured pvp with all of their gear and skills unlocked and just play some casual pickup games or jump into WvW and run with the zerg or solo/smallman smaller objectives. Hardcore players will have the explorer mode dungeons, tournaments for structured pvp or GvG or whatever they want, and can run pre-made WvW groups that can coordinate and create builds capable of taking down the larger pug zerg groups.

  11. #531
    New Spam Forum
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    189
    BG Level
    3
    FFXI Server
    Valefor

    When even the hardcores can't agree on systems, how do you expect companies to address the differences between hardcores and casuals? They can't, so they don't.
    I think you're confusing perfecting a balance/making everyone happy with developing a working system that most people are content to play with. You can't make everyone 100% happy with everything. You CAN make a decent system where most people might have minor gripes, but are enjoying content, and the cool kids can all sit in the corner and bitch about why the event you like sucks.

    Despite the many flaws, FFXI's appeal had a lot to do with its varied end game choices. Casuals are thriving in abyssea, but most of those casuals played before that expansion and were having fun with the game.

    EDIT:
    Quote Originally Posted by Alderaan
    The problem is rewards.
    Honest question: Why should the developer care? Unless it is at extremes (i.e. the change from pre and post abyssea in FFXI) are people really quitting en mass over gear disparity between hardcore and casuals? I'm willing to bet the people who complain about this continue to play most of the time as long as the difference is only moderate.

  12. #532
    D. Ring
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Posts
    4,945
    BG Level
    7
    FFXIV Character
    Grey Jorildyn
    FFXIV Server
    Hyperion

    This kind of discussion is what I pine for when I come to forums. Love it!

    I don't really know why developers would or if they do care about gear disparity, but they've certainly attempted to address it with their token economies. Hardcores play more, earn tokens faster, get the gear quicker. So in that sense the hardcores can have their month in the sun feeling all back-of-the-bus about themselves. The question still remains is that what the players want? Or asked more directly, is that enough to appease the hardcores?

    I'm one of those in the "hardcore but don't care if casuals have the same gear as me". To me I know what I can do with gear like that is greater than what some noob/casual can. Hardcore players (mentality or otherwise) utilize gear to its highest potential, because min/max is part of our philosophy. That begs the question, from me anyway, is why haven't these mmo developers found another way to appease us in that sense? It seems like something we take for granted, and something I cannot even realistically fathom ever changing--the fundamental design behind gear progression. We can talk about elemental resist gear gimmicks, 420/120, "tier 1 gear", etc. until we're blue in the face. It's something that has been a major contributing factor to the stagnancy of this genre for awhile and I think moving away from the WoW model will require innovation in large part to this system.

    Edit: I feel like the spirit of this discussion is encouraging a thread split. At the very least we're certainly not talking about just TOR anymore.

  13. #533
    Eli Manning is my Lord and Savior
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    6,097
    BG Level
    8
    FFXI Server
    Cerberus
    WoW Realm
    Greymane

    Quote Originally Posted by Renzokuken View Post
    Honest question: Why should the developer care? Unless it is at extremes (i.e. the change from pre and post abyssea in FFXI) are people really quitting en mass over gear disparity between hardcore and casuals? I'm willing to bet the people who complain about this continue to play most of the time as long as the difference is only moderate.
    While I'm not going to claim it was the main reason, 1 reason why I stopped playing WoW after The Colliseum raid came out was because of how they started doing the set loot. They were letting people who did heroics and daily dungeons able to buy the same set as raiders, just at lower item values. But considering that, while having the much higher stats is nice, they were able to take advantage of having still decent sets + the nice set bonuses that accompanied these sets(my main was a Resto Druid, and the set bonuses on the sets themselves were generally the thing I looked forward too in some cases more than the stats since it came with buffs to Rejuv/Wild Growth/etc), it really undervalues the amount of work that actually goes into organizing 25 people together to gain something just a few item levels more. I will certainly have my gear faster than majority of the server, but when you're farming the SAME instance for months on end waiting for the next one to be released, by the time it hits people will be wearing it anyway. After the initial progression the raid itself doesn't tend to remain fun to do, when you're doing it to just see some ultra rare drop from the boss there(like Warglaives from Black Temple).

    I really felt Vanilla WoW handled loot perfectly at first. If you raided, you got Tier 1-2. If you didn't raid but you still wanted good loot, you can start out with a Tier 0 set and then build it to the Tier 0.5 set through quests, which buffed them up. The process to upgrade to Tier 0.5 wasn't exactly all easy but it's something a casual can work towards and feel good about earning once they had it, since it took a lot of time and gold to get there. Even when AQ40 and Naxx were prevalent it didn't really diminish its value because outside of raiding gear and the top PvP set it was probably the best.

    Trying to please both hardcore and casuals will never really work, should build the game for one or the other. It's honestly better to just build the game towards hardcore players and throw casuals the occasional bone(Tier 0.5 sets in WoW, +1 af/relic stuff and misc gear in FF11, etc). Trying to build a game towards casuals just frustrates the hardcore players who will leave, and casuals can't be counted on for consistent subscriptions since they don't really have any attachment to stay with the game if something else comes along.

  14. #534
    Most Valuable Lurker
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Posts
    812
    BG Level
    5
    FFXIV Character
    Cayden Fereles
    FFXIV Server
    Sargatanas
    FFXI Server
    Ramuh

    Not related to this discussion, but time to see how this all fleshes out:
    http://www.swtor.com/blog/scheduled-...-april-12-2012

    Cliff notes: Update 1.2 goes live this Thursday

  15. #535
    Like a boss yo
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Posts
    3,852
    BG Level
    7
    FFXI Server
    Odin
    WoW Realm
    Mal'Ganis

    I re-activated for 1.2... if it pans out well, they will have my money for a couple of months.

  16. #536
    Sandworm Swallows
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    7,328
    BG Level
    8

    Quote Originally Posted by Guyverarmor View Post
    I re-activated for 1.2... if it pans out well, they will have my money for a couple of months.
    I have heard that the three main parts of 1.2 are the Legacy system (alt leveling bonuses), UI improvements (I don't know if you can call them improvements more of "this shit should have been in here from the start and it's still not as good as other much shittier games), and a new raid and dungeon.

    As the first two are delayed launch features, is the dungeon and raid really that great as they have been one of the most criticized problems with the game overall?

    Can you tell I am pissed that I wasted $60 on this game? I wish Amazon was doing a buy back on this game, I would gladly trade it for a game with no ending.

  17. #537
    Like a boss yo
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Posts
    3,852
    BG Level
    7
    FFXI Server
    Odin
    WoW Realm
    Mal'Ganis

    No Ringthree, tell us how you REALLY feel..

    But to each their own. Started again, playing a Jedi Guardian, fun so far.

  18. #538
    Relic Horn
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    3,485
    BG Level
    7
    FFXI Server
    Shiva
    WoW Realm
    Stormrage

    Soooo, how many pissed off people that resubbed for ranked warzones?!

  19. #539
    Most Valuable Lurker
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Posts
    812
    BG Level
    5
    FFXIV Character
    Cayden Fereles
    FFXIV Server
    Sargatanas
    FFXI Server
    Ramuh

    Quote Originally Posted by Alderaan View Post
    Soooo, how many pissed off people that resubbed for ranked warzones?!
    I don't even care about the ranked warzones. I find it funny that my champion gear doesn't exist anymore and that BM no longer requires a valor level and is only warzone comms so I'll have a full set in only a day or two. Now I just want to see how the new WZ plays out. As for the new FP, I'm excited because I wanted to continue from where Kaon left off.

  20. #540
    Cerberus
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    451
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Siren
    WoW Realm
    Hydraxis

    Quote Originally Posted by ringthree View Post
    I have heard that the three main parts of 1.2 are the Legacy system (alt leveling bonuses), UI improvements (I don't know if you can call them improvements more of "this shit should have been in here from the start and it's still not as good as other much shittier games), and a new raid and dungeon.

    As the first two are delayed launch features, is the dungeon and raid really that great as they have been one of the most criticized problems with the game overall?

    Can you tell I am pissed that I wasted $60 on this game? I wish Amazon was doing a buy back on this game, I would gladly trade it for a game with no ending.
    But....but.....we get a Guild Bank!!! (More delayed launch features) ^^

Page 27 of 52 FirstFirst ... 17 25 26 27 28 29 37 ... LastLast