Gonna chime in on gold not making near as much as people think. Back before synergy, you could make some gil on the +5 stat rings. There was also kaiser gear (small market).
With the level cap raise, all of the regular synths went away. Nobody wants +5 rings when there are 6 and 7 rings readily available. And no one wants kaiser gear (sat on a -1 piece for 3 months before finally selling it).
Our biggest gil maker atm is desynthing geodes into gems. It's barely worth it or not worth it to make them into rings/earrings on my server. Not to mention you need synergy leveled to do that. Combine that with the fact that no one seems to want any of our new synths, and you have a lot of rather angry goldsmiths.
XI Wiki


