
Originally Posted by
Majidah
I don't think anyone in this thread is taking Tox vs DL personal other than you. I own both hands so I have no reason whether to root for one or another and I have so much philo I have most the philo pets including the wind up qiqirn as to not regret throwing some on the hands.
So let me tell you, 11 crit is much less effective than 2 dex and 8 det. It's not a matter of the accuracy. The bards with highest DPS are *not* the ones with highest crit rate, it's the ones with highest base damage who take the medal.
I highly doubt 11 crit accounts for 1% crit but even if it did, lowering your base damage for 1% crit isn't worth it. It's not a matter of accuracy at all.
Take a look at allagan bracelets (BiS for bard). Dex 13, det 8. Vs dl bracelt, dex 9 crit 9. You are getting dex +4 det +8 crit -9 on that upgrade. And I assure you it's the better choice.
Tox hands aren't bad, but they are definitively not better than DL hands. Under no scenario whatsoever.