In terms of tanking 1 mob, given that I have say, 2GCD worth of time to do something first to grab hate, I've only ever a WHM pull hate off me.
If we're talking about multiple mobs, either due to AoEs or inability to spread hate properly, I've had mobs pulled off by WHM, BLM, BRD, other tanks. This is only talking about the marked (1) mob, don't care shit if you pull (3) because you deserve it.
Although DoTs are potent I don't think I've ever had it overcome flash + scorn spam.
Though then again, only times I've done WP with a SMN there was a BLM involved so the BLM would always overshadow the SMN in hate generation. Perhaps if there wasn't a BLM the SMN could have pulled hate off me.
Yeah WP is pretty much what I'm referring to here. You won't see it much anywhere else.
I rip hate all the time from DF tanks on SCH (and y'know, DF so we're not skipping much and fighting one pack at a time). I tell em FLASH MORE but hey SCH is DPS/Heal/Tank all in one apparently so I'm cool with it.
Think the worst (best) I had was a run where PLD quite literally lost hate on every single pull with more than one mob and never got it back (and even ripped hate for like half of flayer as well). Also on the same run a SMN used Garuda for trash, Titan for flayer (wtf), and Ifrit for demon wall. So that was a thing.
Titan on flayer and ifrit on...well, on anything.
I'll never understand.
People suck at SMN, lol. Gives a horrible perception to the job too, I was in a prae with another SMN yesterday(yay Spiritbonding) and they were doing only Bio2 and ruin while using ifrit. I asked why only bio2 and they said because it's stronger than bio despite the cast time.... <_>
I've also done an AK where I was asked to change to a "real DD" like drg because the other DD was SMN and they though we couldn't kill wall with two "weak dps classes".
Oh, and there was the time I was told id be kicked from the party if I didn't stop auto attacking because the leader had enough of melee mages in XI and he just wouldn't stand for it in xiv.
Adding damage to your damage is bad, mk.
List could go on forever, people are dumb.
You play with shit SMN's :X
Duty Finder in a nutshell.
I'm trying to improve my PLD friend's AoE tanking so we could maybe speed up WPs and such, but I feel like AoE tanking was deliberately meant to be rough if your DPS are going all out with it. Unless there's some trick I can pass off to him to make it easier.
I've heard of this melee mage stuff a few times now but I'm too terrified to do it on SCH am I a bad?
Also, this fucking botany leve at Whitebrim is bugged and doesn't spawn 8 nodes, only 7. Going to kill myself.
Utilize cover if not doing so already.
When I do WP SR without a bard it's a complete pain in the ass. Loss of FR means that nukes aren't as hard and stuff lasts longer. Loss of MB means that I rarely have enough MP to hold hate which ends with dead BLMs. Still trying to find a way to fix it, even with riot blades constantly I can't hold hate without a bard.
To hit on my fairy
Literally the first thing I checked on rolling ACN was if you could, in fact, hit shit with your book.
This is serious business.