2013-14 NFL Week 4: Paper, rock, ded

[archibaldcrane]

How was Vick's MNF drubbing of the redskins not on there? He was +8.5 throwing, +3.9 rushing. 20/24 for 330 yds, 4 TDs

edit: you meant from 2010, see below

[tyven]

lolololololololol

[archibaldcrane]

How was Vick's MNF drubbing of the redskins not on there? He was +8.5 throwing, +3.9 rushing. 20/24 for 330 yds, 4 TDs

He was +8.5 total, including his +3.5 rushing - but yeah that should be tied for 10th on the list.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blo...s-at-redskins/

I tweeted at the guy who runs it to get a correction for you.

Also, we witnessed one of the greatest edge rusher games together, the Clay Matthews dismantling of Kolb, and then Vick week 1 of 2011.

[archibaldcrane]

Why can't I just break down NFL stats for a living, instead of getting paid 6 bills a day to do it for free on the internet while I should be working?

[Abandon]

fuck you

[Chun Liroy]

both of you should shut the hell up. Derek Anderson was a fucking boss that one season, and Palmer before getting his knee wrecked was better than Romo will ever be. oh, but bloo bloo bloo, he hasn't had a great season since!

looooooooooool

[chazzyphizzle]

derek anderson is #1 in my heart because of the press conference of all press conferences when he was in AZ

[Moss]

RB list is interesting

not surprised to see 2008 Michael Turner on there, such a beast back then

[archibaldcrane]

looooooooooool

His 2006 season stacks right up with the best of Romo, and it was only his sophomore campaign. He led the league in completion % and TDs, neither of which Romo has ever done.

[Chun Liroy]

His 2006 season stacks right up with the best of Romo, and it was only his sophomore campaign. He led the league in completion % and TDs, neither of which Romo has ever done.

Cherry pick stats more archie. You are better than this. His highest TD (36, which is more than Palmers btw), just happened to be the same season that Brady threw for 50 TDs.

Palmer isn't even as good as Romo, let alone "better than he'll ever be."

[Penthesilea]

He was +8.5 total, including his +3.5 rushing - but yeah that should be tied for 10th on the list.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blo...s-at-redskins/

I tweeted at the guy who runs it to get a correction for you.

Also, we witnessed one of the greatest edge rusher games together, the Clay Matthews dismantling of Kolb, and then Vick week 1 of 2011.

Ah okay yeah I had looked at that link and just saw that he was +8.5 with them later on mentioning his +3.9 rushing, so I assumed that wasn't included in the 8.5.

[Abandon]

Cherry pick stats more archie. You are better than this. His highest TD (36, which is more than Palmers btw), just happened to be the same season that Brady threw for 50 TDs.

Palmer isn't even as good as Romo, let alone "better than he'll ever be."

[archibaldcrane]

Cherry pick stats more archie. You are better than this. His highest TD (36, which is more than Palmers btw), just happened to be the same season that Brady threw for 50 TDs.

Palmer isn't even as good as Romo, let alone "better than he'll ever be."

The point is that before his clearly career-changing injury, Palmer was as good as Romo at his best (leading the fucking Bengals to 11 wins with a passer rating over 100 while leading the NFL in TDs and completion %) and it was only his 2nd season.

Clearly the post-injury Carson Palmer is not as good as Romo, but we're talking pre-injury.

Romo's 36 TDs would be more impressive if they weren't such a result of rampant gunslinging - he threw 19 INTs that year too...which in another year would've been the most INTs in a season.

Which year you ask?

Oh, 2012, when Romo lead the league in INTs with 19.

[archibaldcrane]

If you can't even get a 2:1 TD/INT ratio, it's hard to rave about your season in the modern NFL. Romo's not even 2:1 for his career.

[archibaldcrane]

It's kinda funny - when you look at the best 7-season comp for Romo...

Milt Plum, Aaron Brooks, Drew Brees, Carson Palmer

[Aragon of Odin]

If you can't even get a 2:1 TD/INT ratio, it's hard to rave about your season in the modern NFL. Romo's not even 2:1 for his career.

In Romos defence, he's only 1 TD away from being having that 2:1 ratio lol

Also, Palmer pre-injury wasn't even 2:1

[archibaldcrane]

In Romos defence, he's only 1 TD away from being having that 2:1 ratio lol

Also, Palmer pre-injury wasn't even 2:1

Yeah, he had a "beat up the rookie" year, and then a 32:12 year, and then a terrible injury. It's called projection.

[Aragon of Odin]

He had 2 more season after that 32:12, a 28:13 and a 26:20, after his amazing year he started to decline.

[Chun Liroy]

Comparing Palmer stats from 1 year and projecting it over the course of career as if he would keep it up. Lol.

Higher %
high passer rating
9 less TDs
42 less ints

All in a season less of work.

Should compare Romo to shit ass tom bardy tbh

[AidenCarby]

Let me know when Romo's good enough to lose two Superbowls to Eli Manning.