Based on your descriptions that would put Warthog stewpot 100-102 if you can check what rank it is that can be used to narrow it down some. Slices of marinara pizza at 40.
Slices of margherita pizza at 50. Slices of pepperoni pizza at confusing since wiki has the crepes as 60 and depending on which recipe the cookies at 58 or 60... either way it shouldn't be be possible no matter what level it is to be right between those 2 unless bg wiki is wrong on the other 2. I guess I'll check. Slices of anchovy pizza I think 68 but again order seems weird.
Edit: Warthog is veteran so definitely 100. Seems the order is all out of whack on bg wiki for the 60s but assuming the levels are right yeah the achovy should be 68. Pepperoni is definitely between ham and cheese and ginger which bg wiki both lists as 60. Which pretty much means either ham and cheese and the pepperoni pizza before it on the comp list are actually 59 and bg wiki is wrong listing them as 60 or SE decided for this one recipe to change how they order things. But the slices should be 60. Guild merchants don't sell the pizza cutters