
Originally Posted by
Xajii
I dunno... feel strongly that down the stretch bats were a bigger need than pitching for them.
In the long run, it's good to get Cespedes' silly contract off the books in Oakland, but they did just give up a heating-up bat for a rental that will spearhead a rotation that was already quite silly. Oakland's problem going into the playoffs wasn't going to be pitching IMO, especially considering many AL competitors have shown offenses that are liable to say "fuck your starter's sub-3 ERA". Orioles, Tigers, Angels all have been able to consistently light up aces. Lester's impact on that rotation just does not wow me when you've got a guy like Tommy Milone ready to push out lolHammel within the next week or so at the back end.
A's historic run differential has largely been carried by a huge first half, and a lot of those bats have cooled considerably.
Boston did okay here, but I have a hard time believing this was the best offer on the table - we know Cespedes' ceiling (incredible defender, .250 20 HR bat) and we could probably even inflate those power numbers a bit moving from O.co to Fenway. But he's got a contract that isn't really the best and I just have to believe there were prospects on the table that very well could have panned out to be much better.
Unless Boston flips Cespedes, I personally am not wowed by this trade for either side.