Her Crisis Core (Andrea Bowen) one works too:
Maybe more justiable as she's 5 years younger in Crisis Core. So the change in Advent Children I mentally treated it as an "older" voice.
But given the trend it'll probably change again. So ... do we pick from celebs or anime VAs?
Would Scarlett Johansson work? In the movie "Her" I enjoyed her voice work:
If she adjusts it to be less coarse (or my speakers suck) I could see it working.
Alternatively, another voice that jumps to mind is Bridgit Mendler (Arietty):
It's got that sharp/peppy punch to it, which I think can be well suited to Aerith.
Ultimately it can't go wrong whatever they pick. Liked it in KH, liked it in CC, was "ok" in AC. Should still work.
XI Wiki



