
Originally Posted by
Gredival
HNMLS were you had to apply, trial, and be accepted then maintain sufficient status to be eligible for your items created a much deeper social interaction than letting everyone low man everything in Abyssea or shoutgroup everything else post-Abyssea.
Well a bunch of you did exactly that about the HNMLS system and you eventually got shit ruined
I'm one of those people who had to jump around a few shells and servers for over a year before getting my Hecatomb Cap and Subligar.
The system worked.
The problem I encountered was never establishing reputation to be lot eligible (or, to be more realistic, getting DKP priority since most shells moved towards that and most probationary periods lasted 2-3 weeks at most), it was the item scarcity outlasting the Linkshell lifetime. When I finally sucked it up and leveled WHM to get into an actual power shell, and not just trying to join whatever shell would accept a DPS or tank at the time, I easily topped the DKP charts for the shell and easily won lots on my items. Hell, I only got my Defending Ring because panda didn't want to let the only main tank (a very recently off-trial member) have it
I can tell you that on my journey, all the people in shells that already had items were the core players who would be on all the time and could be summoned to events as necessary. All the have-nots complaining about not having a chance at items (ShepardG) were infrequent attendees and just there to vacuum up whatever they could.
Nah there's everything wrong with that. This shit was stupid, and I say that as someone who got a Relic funded by selling King items.
You want a Ridill? Your ass should be in the pit. Not just to pay someone for it, but every day to earn the DKP for it. And you should have the gear and skill not to be a burden and kicked before your turn comes up. Otherwise, I'd rather give it to the person who only plays mage jobs in the HNMLS.
Not everyone should get every item. Your progression should be limited by your ability to do the content required to get the item, including competing with other Linkshells and your Linkshell peers.
This is the point of the EX tag. You have to acquire the item yourself. People can pay mercs for items through the AH.