
Originally Posted by
arus2001
Sorry, but SE did not make a perfect game. If anything, it was a lot of bumbling through "first times" where we can easily see future development of some content getting scrapped or just plain undercooked to say there's something most often padded by inane grinds. Not to reiterate the whole cycle of "What is Classic?!" and the impossibility of faithfully recreating the retail experience of the time with 1/10th a server's population at best, but the ability to smooth out the imperfections is actually a private server's biggest strength. Problem is, a lot of these places have neither the vision nor capability to pull it off. And it doesn't help having free ride cultists nipping at their heels when their nostalgic purity is defiled or legitimate bullshit comes to light.
Much as we may have all personally enjoyed XI at some point, the rise of WoW clones inevitably tells the story of its imperfections. What strengths XI had simply weren't enough for most players of the era if they even deigned to give the game a chance. The weaknesses most certainly did it no favors.