Let me add these :
-- Promathia added a kickass storyline that could give things to do to every player for a long time, other than exp, and that did not require them to be lv60+ or play 15 hours a day; Zilart did not.
-- Promathia added most forced pop NMs that would not bring lots and lots of drama; Zilart did not.
Imo Promathia and Zilart were not done in the same goal or orientation, no new jobs actually sucked but there's something else than count how much exp areas were added, there's something more than exp and gear in this game. Zilart was made to be easy (let's call your 75 friends and leech sky access !) but you had to wait for you to be lv60+, Promathia was made to be challenging and you could start at lv30, and i think was much more closer to other FF games.
Other than that, i understand people who don't give a fuck about fun and want gear, gear, more gear and kickass titles with easy fights, but i'm not one of these and i wouldn't pay for playing if that was the only thing you could do in the game.
