
Originally Posted by
llenomor
I can confirm that all you need to do is hit the captain with a normal hit when the monkey isn't looking for 3 chests.
It's very easy if you time it right and have weapons drawn before you try. I was able to surprise him this way without sneak, invis, sneak attack, flee, or anything else. I just ran up and smacked him, and we did get all 3 chests.
Also note range attack doesn't work. You will get the "surprise" message if you hit him with range but you will not get the 3rd chest.
Last night night we did this again, and got only two chests. I'm not sure what's going wrong.
This time, I pulled out my weapon, used powder boots, then ran behind him and whacked him once.
He said "Huh? What are you doing here?"
I ran away and, once I was out of range I automatically disengaged, which made him go yellow. But then I cast Dia on him to reclaim him. He never lost hate on me during this time, however. He continued to chase me around until the monkey died then I brought the Captain down to my PT. I was in the middle of another pair of powder boots so I just ran down and waited for the captain. After a few seconds he didn't show up, so I ran back up to get him and he was shooting at me again as soon as I was in range, so I don't think I lost hate. I would always recast Dia every so often while kiting, too, and he never went back home during the process.
Maybe I lost hate briefly when I took him to my PT?
Not sure what I'm doing wrong.