I did Arrapago Saturday night (Feb 24th) with 11 people, planning to hit the marks that drop 35s.
I've never spent so much fucking time on the first floor. We got magic easy enough, but everything else just wouldn't drop. It took about 50 minutes for other things to start trickling in, but I positively hate it when people have to sit around for an hour while the hand-to-handers throw their punches.
We had one THF, and all but one killshot was delivered by a member of the THF's PT. I think you guys just got the good Arrapago server.