
Originally Posted by
Yugl
While that is true, I find that most justifications for 'why the manga is better' are blatant lies.
I've recently been heckled by one person who keeps trying to annoy me by saying "Bleach is bad bleach is terrible blah blah" and more recently, he's been IMing me constantly about how manga is better than anime for Bleach (Funny, isn't it?). One of his examples was Noitra (SP) putting his finger in Orihime's mouth in the manga as opposed to using his hand to cover the mouth in the anime. I asked why he likes the manga more ffor that scene than in the anime. He says he likes to see the author's original intent (That which comes first and the manga came first). I then asked which he would choose if the had anime used the finger and the manga had used the hand. He said he would pick the anime. Clearly, what he wanted was the fingering and not the 'original intent' since that was the only thing that changed (original intent is the same) in the hypothetical and he claimed he would pick the anime.
I personally prefer the anime since I like the animation. For example, when he uses Getsugatensho to part the clouds. You just don't get that same effect when looking at still images.
Now he's trying to bitch to me about how difficult formal logic is.