Leveling pld to 75(post shield update/autorefresh, pre-sentinal update) I grew to HATE the "pld no thx" attitude from a few brds and rdms.
I won't lie, I had those 2k/hour parties(smn healer, no backup, no refresh), but I also had those 10k+/hour at level 66 parties. Give me a constant 4/tick(counting autorefresh) and there will never be downtime. Give me rdm+brd(with a brd that won't just give me minuets when the melee don't fucking listen) and I'll mainheal the party while tanking and never lose hate and the rdm can just sit there and haste/refresh/enfeeble/regen and never bother with cures at all and all the melee can go apeshit sub war and it won't matter.
So its not like theres anything about the pld job that leads to low exp/hour, at least pre merit parties(I'll agree, I don't merit with plds unless they're friends in need of buffer/merits and I know they'll be bringing DD gear).
That being said, and my own little indignation out of the way at being automatically turned down when I ask a lfp brd if they want to party because they assume the exp will suck out of the way, I DO have to admit that the majority of pickup plds suck ass through a straw.
But then so do a majority of the Nins. We've all seen the plds that never use mp and eat boiled crab from 1-75 sure, but I've seen nins offhanding that int/mp sword meleeing in cotehardie, and I would guess that about 99% of the Nin population is incapable of counting to 3. Can't hold hate, can't do damage, can't keep from bleeding mp worse than a blind counterstanced mnk, pickup nins suck too, though admittedly most nins will still give you more exp/hour then your typical never cures pld.
And in fact, most players in general suck ass through a straw, and some just hide behind the fact that they have servicable gear and can just auto attack and afk(hi2u 90% of people that play DD jobs).
What really gets me is that most of the really good brds and rdms I know will at least try out a party as long as the setup isn't insanely stupid(5 melee, all /war, none of them nin, invite a brd), and then if it sucks I don't blame em for leaving. Most of the time, the prissy "I'm too good for your exp parties" rdm and brds that I meet ALSO suck ass through a straw. Asking a pickup rdm to do anything more complicated than refresh 2 people is often asking too much. God forbid you ask them to sleep links with a darkstaff instead of melee with their AF weapon.
THAT being said, the moral of the story is that its not that 90% of PLDs suck and automatically restrict you to 3k/hour. Its that 90% of PLAYERS suck, and if you're time is really valuable and you want to make sure you get max exp/hour, you make a set with a rdm and a brd in it, level a few nights a week, and avoid any and all pickup parties at all cost.
If you flag up though, and its not immediately obvious that the person inviting you is an idiot, you should at least give it a chance barring the aforementioned idiotic setups(and even then, sometimes Im curios enough to come along just to see how bad it will fail. Might get a good laugh out of it at least). If you weren't prepared for the horrors of potentially bad pickup parties, you shouldn't have flagged up in the first place.
XI Wiki


