As a first job MNK and long time NIN, I'm gonna have to agree with Aurik on this one. Although MNK can't reliably solo a Very Tough+ like a NIN can, the effect on their ability to solo anything lower is pretty well the same as the effect on a NIN. The only advantage NIN really has over MNK [for mobs of this class, Tough and lower] is that NINs have 2 things that help them solo mage type mobs: Paralyze and the ability to sub another job (in this case, DRK for Stun). The mob's family has little to do with it.
Where the mob family comes into play is when you start taking a peeker at the VT+ mobs. A NIN can still solo most mob classes that are VT, whereas a MNK stands no chance against a good portion of them. Something such as a Mamool Ja, for example, gives both jobs a hard time. Whereas a VT spider might rape a MNK for all its worth as soon as it gets Slow off, while I NIN will just laugh and evade all its hits, even if they can't Erase the Slow. The spider is a bad example, because even on MNK I evade them regularly at that level, but you get the idea.
Aurik: Yesterday, I got Behemoth to 59% in about 16 minutes before my Bard arrived. That would have added up to a ~35 minute kill solo. Obviously MNK/NIN does more damage more regularly than a NIN/WAR, so I have no doubt you can solo Behemoth after patch. However, I've been told many many times that Behemoth's rage timer is still 60 minutes, regardless of being NQ. Not 30min like Adamantoise. Does anyone have proof or first-hand experience with either? Currently it seems to all be heresay.Originally Posted by aurik
XI Wiki

