Not with the huge acc boost to 2 handersOriginally Posted by fantasticdan
Not with the huge acc boost to 2 handersOriginally Posted by fantasticdan
2h wielders have pretty much capped accuracy on colibri with no merits and no mad/hunters roll, I dont think any amount of zhanshin is going to help all that much..
except it was already pretty much the best body for a meat build; and comes with the 'extra' store tp you'd need to make a sword strap build great katana still 6 hits. *shrugs*Originally Posted by divisortheory
There is good enough evidence to suggest that Guard proc-rates might have increased via the update. Here is the thread I posted that links a lol-Alla thread:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=22831
The way the one-handed cap works:
cRatio itself is no longer capped, for any weapon.
pdif is calculated from cRatio the same way it used to be, and then the new caps are applied on the resulting value.
One-handed non-crit: 2.0
One-handed crit: 3.0
Two-handed crit or non-crit: 3.0
In effect, one-handed wielders have their damage significantly reduced during the ~1.6 to ~2.4 cRatio interval (in other words, not on Too Weak).
Below ~1.6 cRatio there is no change, and above ~2.4 the result is a slight buff.
In practice, without buffs this negatively affects soloing EP-T things, with buffs it negatively affects T-low IT battles.
naga: do you have information about the level adjustment penalty yet?
I hit a couple points higher on DC than I was expecting to yesterday when checking my damage (I can give you all my numbers if you need it.) and the simplest solution I could find, assuming our estimates of lesser colibri stats are accurate, is that the level adjustment now works in our favor if we're higher level than the target.
The Str 1 : Attack 1 and Dex 1: Acc 1 is only a bonus from gear attributes correct?
Originally Posted by shirak
Originally Posted by Zirk
That was just proven to be wrong, actually.
Correct, Sinroth, Nitecon and El_Dez were going over it in IRC and worked out it's only stats from gear and not base stats.Originally Posted by LD
Do you mean just the dex thing? Because my atk definitely goes up by 1 point for every point of strength from my base stats.Originally Posted by Fallso
I'm pretty sure they worked it out as STR/DEX/whatever not affecting 2 handers any more than it affects 1 handers.Originally Posted by Ryko
[14:07] <El_Dez> apparently base stats also count
[14:07] <Siniroth> link? I wanna see how they tested it
[14:07] <Nitecon> well, my str is at 75 base attack no wpn 55
[14:08] <Nitecon> equip polearm my attack goes to 387
[14:08] <Siniroth> need a 2h weapon equipped for the change in attack to take place
[14:08] <El_Dez> nit
[14:08] <El_Dez> yea
[14:08] <Siniroth> for stat conversion
[14:08] <El_Dez> what he said
[14:08] <Siniroth> oh
[14:08] <Siniroth> do you have a grip?
[14:08] <Nitecon> no grip
[14:08] <Nitecon> naked
[14:08] <Siniroth> but do you have one, at all?
[14:08] <Nitecon> pole skill 292
[14:08] <Nitecon> axe
[14:09] <Siniroth> equip just the grip, no polearm, if it lets you
[14:09] <Nitecon> cant
[14:09] <El_Dez> I heard it lets you
[14:09] <El_Dez> really?
[14:09] <Siniroth> hmm
[14:09] <El_Dez> huh
[14:09] <El_Dez> well
[14:09] <El_Dez> be naked and equip your spear
[14:09] <Siniroth> equip both, switch jobs, put polearm into moghouse, switch jobs back
[14:09] <Siniroth> forces it to equip XD
[14:09] <Nitecon> okok omw back to MH
[14:10] <El_Dez> subtract spear skill and your +10 att trait bonus
[14:10] <El_Dez> and you should have your answer
[14:10] <Nitecon> 387 - 10 - 292
[14:11] <Siniroth> without the +10 attack, his attack, if str didnt have a different effect on 2h weapons with base stats, should be 357
[14:11] <Siniroth> er, 347
[14:11] <Siniroth> 357 with the +10
[14:11] <Nitecon> ok naked drg with axe grip
[14:11] <Siniroth> what's att?
[14:11] <Nitecon> my attack is 57
[14:11] <Nitecon> fully naked it's 55
[14:12] <Siniroth> stats on grip?
[14:12] <El_Dez> test if 2H mechanics apply
[14:12] <Nitecon> +3 str
[14:12] <El_Dez> by equipping a STR ring
[14:12] <Nitecon> added flame ring
[14:12] <Nitecon> only 2 attack
[14:12] <Siniroth> then nvm, it's not a 2h weapon
[14:12] <El_Dez> ah
[14:12] <Siniroth> bah
[14:13] <Siniroth> well still, 55 base attack, + 292 skill + 10 att bonus = 357, not 387
[14:13] <El_Dez> hmmm
[14:13] <Nitecon> my str is 75+2
[14:14] <Siniroth> do you happen to have anything that has -str?
[14:14] <Siniroth> that might do it
[14:14] <Nitecon> hmmm i can get on blm and equip staff + errant
[14:14] <Siniroth> k
[14:15] <Siniroth> we need att before errant, and difference in str and att when errant's equipped
[14:15] <Nitecon> naked blm 40 attack 64 str
[14:15] <Nitecon> with staff 312 attack
[14:15] <Siniroth> staff skill?
[14:15] <Nitecon> staff capped 240
[14:16] =-= Aikar|AFK is now known as Aikar
[14:16] <Nitecon> with errant str is 64-7
[14:16] <Nitecon> attack is now 305
[14:16] <Siniroth> yeah, normal stats effect it
[14:16] <Siniroth> >_> I could tell without errant, actually
[14:17] <El_Dez> erm
[14:17] <Nitecon> base stats don't affect it i just worked it out
[14:17] <Siniroth> other way around, they dont, but stats that take away from it do
[14:17] <El_Dez> all that proves is gear stat - affects it
[14:17] <Nitecon> 240 skill + 40 base + 64/2 = 312
[14:17] <Siniroth> >_> so 64 str will give 32 attack, but, 64-4 strength will give 32-4 att
[14:18] <Siniroth> yeah
[14:18] <Nitecon> 312 is my attack with staff only
[14:18] <Nitecon> so base stats do not affect str=attk ratio
2 HanderOriginally Posted by Fallso
http://img401.imageshack.us/img401/5797/uhwhatcx0.jpg
1 Hander
http://img260.imageshack.us/img260/4889/uhwhat2dv4.jpg
Unless I'm misunderstanding what the mean by base stats, tell em to lay off the good stuff![]()
Nit may have screwed up, but I had no reason to doubt him.
When I logged out before the update I was a DRG/SAM with 75+17 STR and 400ish attack (I really wish I could remember the exact number but it was about 400 give or take maybe 5). When I logged in, my attack was 447. With only +17 STR in gear it should have only gone up about 8 or 9 if base stats aren't included, but instead went up 45ish. If you take into account base STR, then with a total of 92 STR it would have gone up by 46, which is about how much it increased. I'm inclined to believe that base stats also get the 1 STR = 1 attack calculation. Maybe someone who remembers what their exact stats were before and after the update could confirm that more conclusively.
Those screenshots leave some sort of doubt in your mind? Unless they were shopped they're rock solid.Originally Posted by Obiron
I had more attack with a staff (218 skill) on whitemage, than I did with a club (244 skill) on whitemage. with no +str/+att gear. (base str 61)
the exact attack numbers were:
staff: 287 -> this is exactly: 8 + 218 + 61
club: 282 -> this is exactly: 8 + 244 + 30
when I added my AF+1 mitts, my new numbers were (61+7 str):
staff: 294 -> this is exactly: +7
club: 286 -> this is exactly: +4 ((1+7)/2)
base stats are included in the 1 STR = 1 ATT calculation.
I'll take screenshots when I get home if needed.
Oh no, I didn't post that because I have doubts. I trust Ryko's pics. I just wanted to add in some before and after info (although admittedly maybe it wasn't the most helpful post without remembering my exact pre-update stats) to help seal the deal. I'm a believer that it applies to base stats as well.Originally Posted by Talisien
Learn to math! How dare you doubt my quotes!
Originally Posted by George Bush
No offense to Ryko, but he shows 2h attack and str with drk using scythe and 1h with war and a sword. AFAIK drk get smore attack bonus then war does and sword is not wars A+ weapon. Show me those same changes using a drk with sword and gaxe (same skill cap) and I will believe base stats do not count. But my attack before buffs was not over 460 pre-patch, it it now 509. I also have higher attack on my bst using a scythe over an axe now.
Edit:unless he was trying to prove base str=att