GAxe vs Axe vs Sword Parse results.

[Arthars]

Well just went to test how great GAxe is so i picked up someone that is able to do a fair parse with me.
Our gears should be acceptable, so here goes. And sorry for parser headers because they seem to be messed up but you guys should know which is which i guess. This is kinda test PT, as we picked up a BST to test her call beast timer on various pets. But still managed to keep entire chain going, so its ok i think.

Camp is colibri, so obviously ridill/joy is better than axe/ridill. But we made it 3 way parse(me being full time axe/ridill, Kyraa being GAxe 1sthour, Sword 2nd hour) to kinda compare the 3 setups.

Both of us WAR/NIN tho for standard meripo style. Song is minuet + madrigal, and we skipped food to be fair. and only took parse result of us 2, as the other is a BST ^^

clearing up a bit:
M Hit % = melee hit % aka accurancy
M Ht / Ms: i dont know lol
M Hi/Lo: melee highest damage hit/lowest damage hit
M Avg: Melee average
SK Avg: a screw up header from his parser. This is Highest WS damage/Lowest WS damage.
SK #: another screwed up header. This is WS average damage
Crit #: Critical %


Arthars: Axe/Ridill
Kyraa: Gaxe
http://mectradegroup.com/FFXI/AxeGaxe.JPG
axe being kinda better abit. But the acc is hax -_- 1 dex = 1 acc is too powerful O_O. Average raging rush is crazy as well(NOTE: NO SEA GORGET FOR RAGING RUSH).


Arthars: Axe/Ridill
Kyraa: ridill/joyuese
http://mectradegroup.com/FFXI/SwordAxe.JPG
sword being better than axe for colibri(he always beats me in colibri with ridill/joy dex setup)

No, no penta trust comparision thanks. Because we wanna be fair, we pick slashing to compete.

He gotta try /SAM next pt i think.

[Codernaut]

interesting... but I gotta say it

lolgorgets

[Arthars]

shit.......theres a topic on dual wield VS 2H

i shouldnt have make new topic i guess >.> sorry

possible to move it over?

[Retrieving/C.D/Searain]

What a confusing post. Cliffnotes? Or perhaps I'm just sleepy but you messed up /c boxes and omitted lots of stuff from the parser.

[Lordwafik]

What a confusing post. Cliffnotes? Or perhaps I'm just sleepy but you messed up /c boxes and omitted lots of stuff from the parser.

Welcome to the magical world of Arthars's posting.

It's like Walt Disney just gave you a blowjob, you feel akward during it and want to cry when you're done.

[Arthars]

those headers from his parser is messed up, which i already mention when i started the thread

its not my fault lol i am merely posting them up

i removed stuffs like evasion, parry etc etc thats irrelevant

and wafik i think you are derailing

mod?

nevermind you like to abuse your mod power in this forum anyway

[Laika]

What a confusing post. Cliffnotes? Or perhaps I'm just sleepy but you messed up /c boxes and omitted lots of stuff from the parser.

You're sleepy. Most of the stuff you pointed out is accounted for.

[Poopfacekilla]

One day I aspire to understand that analogy.

[Lordwafik]

those headers from his parser is messed up, which i already mention when i started the thread

its not my fault lol i am merely posting them up

i removed stuffs like evasion, parry etc etc thats irrelevant

and wafik i think you are derailing

mod?

nevermind you like to abuse your mod power in this forum anyway

I'm not a mod tardicus.

[Shuvo]

Think your results were that Ridill/joy war outparsed Byakko Axe war by ~15% in identical gear? Having trouble understanding...

[Tdizzle]

Think your results were that Ridill/joy war outparsed Byakko Axe war by ~15% in identical gear? Having trouble understanding...

Thought it was more like 5% which is too close for comfort from the ridill camp.

[Arthars]

kyraa's ridill/joy dex setup outparse my axe/ridill in colibri always

his crit rate is high and joyuese piercing kinda cool VS colibri

he dont/seldom use ridill/joy on mamools tho, cos axe better for mamools.

[JeanClaudVanDamme]

So, with a better GA like, say, Fortitude/Martial/Rune Chopper and a better sub like SAM or DRG, would it be right to say that GA WAR > Ridill WAR officially now? I won't even bring up Bravura, cuz I'm pretty sure at this point it's 100% Relic GA WAR > Ridill WAR.

[aurik]

Basically what Arthars discovered is that using a full dex setup with a 2h weapon when
1) crit pdif cap = normal pdif cap
2) acc = 95%
is a bad idea.

[Arthars]

yea i think 2H is not going to have any trouble with acc at all now

1 dex = 1 acc is crazy, i think every good 2Handers out there are parsing 95-97% acc now

can go more into att or str i guess, unless you still want a minor boost in crit hit %?

and i strongly believe a relic gaxe war with /sam is definately better than a ridill war now :O

[Sci]

Did the G.Axe user in this test have any G.Axe merits? I'm guessing none, but that's another thing that should be factored in.

[Retrieving/C.D/Searain]

The whole thread should be moved to allakhazam.

[Jotaru]

and i strongly believe a relic gaxe war with /sam is definately better than a ridill war now :O

What has this world come to, when Relic's outparse Ridill.. /cry.

[Don Katsu]

Think your results were that Ridill/joy war outparsed Byakko Axe war by ~15% in identical gear? Having trouble understanding...

5% and the Byakko Axe WAR wasn't even subbing SAM.

[Septimus]

and i strongly believe a relic gaxe war with /sam is definately better than a ridill war now :O

What has this world come to, when Relic's outparse Ridill.. /cry.

What are you talking about? Ridill is Warrior relic.