Dagger choice.. X's vs BD.

[Saeriel]

You're a fucking idiot, I was never Thf main but I always knew that TA was a guaranteed crit after Assassin.

I think you missed the boat on that one by a while... *sigh*

[Yutuyu]

[quote=Fallso]

TA is not a guaranteed crit.

Please tell me you didn't really just say this.

TA damage enhancement is not a crit. If you think it is, then you're clueless.

Wow, you really did say it. Can you explain why the chat log says you scored a critical hit every time then?

Cause I'm not a thief main and didn't know assassin makes TA guaranteed critical. My mistake, in that case, it's a nice boost either way on the first WS hit.

If you don't know, why did you even comment?

I've done X's knife tests with a friend so I knew that. But my THF is only 37, so I didn't know what Assassin did that.

You're a fucking idiot, I was never Thf main but I always knew that TA was a guaranteed crit after Assassin.[/quote:fdb96]



Granted, it was obviously a mistake to not know such a basic thing and embarassing to have made a fool out of myself by asserting something which wasn't true. But uh... don't you think it's even dumber to claim that a person is an idiot based off of one mistake than it is to have made a single mistake? I guess you've never done anything stupid in your life.

[archibaldcrane]

Mandau/X's = higher SAMS damage than Mandau/Blau? I think they'll be pretty much even but would be interesting to find out if X's is a better sub.

I don't think there's any question that it would provide a higher SAMS or TAMS. The only question is whether it's lower DPS and lack of acc/atk bonus would hurt TPing damage too much.

Plus...well, Mandau+X's? Who the fuck has both?

Oh, and stop piling on Yutuyu - he was retarded, but at least he eventually owned up to it (and it was like 2 weeks ago at this point).

[Aurara]

Mandau/X's = higher SAMS damage than Mandau/Blau? I think they'll be pretty much even but would be interesting to find out if X's is a better sub.

I don't think there's any question that it would provide a higher SAMS or TAMS. The only question is whether it's lower DPS and lack of acc/atk bonus would hurt TPing damage too much.

Plus...well, Mandau+X's? Who the fuck has both?

Oh, and stop piling on Yutuyu - he was retarded, but at least he eventually owned up to it (and it was like 2 weeks ago at this point).

Kingadem on ifrit has both ~.~

[Fallso]

Granted, it was obviously a mistake to not know such a basic thing and embarassing to have made a fool out of myself by asserting something which wasn't true. But uh... don't you think it's even dumber to claim that a person is an idiot based off of one mistake than it is to have made a single mistake? I guess you've never done anything stupid in your life.

I've never pretended to know what I'm talking about when I don't.

[sakurato]

everyone go for dagger today, one of us is bound to get it XD

[vagus]

everyone go for dagger today, one of us is bound to get it XD

Sholo got one today. lol.

[sakurato]

empty chest for me ; ; ; sigh. next week!

[Loren]

Aww, everyone's enthusiasm is so adorable.
I think I lost my soul somewhere around the 0/35 mark.

[dawdr]

Do you keep on truckin' without the soul though? I know I did. I think the key to getting the knife is giving up all hope.

[Yutuyu]

Granted, it was obviously a mistake to not know such a basic thing and embarassing to have made a fool out of myself by asserting something which wasn't true. But uh... don't you think it's even dumber to claim that a person is an idiot based off of one mistake than it is to have made a single mistake? I guess you've never done anything stupid in your life.

I've never pretended to know what I'm talking about when I don't.

You did claim I'm an idiot based off of 1 mistake. So... yeah, actually you did.

[Imladra]

Plus...well, Mandau+X's? Who the fuck has both?

Didelito on asura got his X a couple of months ago. But i don't think he tried to parse the difference.

He told me he eyeballed it though and it was noticeable for him.
Maybe i could push him to test it.

[Imladra]

Oops Didn't check the posting date. It's an old thread.