
Originally Posted by
Zekyr
I can agree with this, pre-2h update unless you were a DRG or DRK carrying homam and HQ gear, an AH barone/hauberk/AF2 war or mnk could easily outparse you without even trying. With the best AH and some EX gear on my DRK, I'd still parse within 2-3% of a WAR/NIN using random STR rings and crap like fransisca in merit parties, and be a larger MP sponge as well regardless of keeping seigan up fulltime.
Right after the 2h update, it went the other way, and AF and AH DRGs DRKs and SAMs were kicking the ass of ridill adaberk wars and BB mnks. Yes, that was busted as hell as well, some people said "oh it's fair, we were behind and now we're ahead, tough luck" but it wasn't balanced.
After the next update, they changed damage caps, changed the random damage generator, and to be perfectly honest apart from SAM everything was nearly perfect. AH DRKs and DRGs parsed about the same as AH MNKs and WARs. My DRK which is about as good as I can make it apart from adaberk, homam, or relic has beaten and been beaten by similarly equipped 1h jobs (BB/haidate/merited MNKs, haidate and excellent AH gear WARs) depending on mobs and skill level. Elite geared DRKs parse close to the elite geared WARs. Most of all that was nearly balanced, with a slight favoring towards 2h from some pieces of gear.
SAM was a different case, having been nearly on par with 1h due to it's abilities even before the 2h update, and completely broken afterwards, yes. No one will argue that. But they didn't need to fuck with everyone else's 2h jobs just to fix SAM.
The acc=dex and atk=str update was fine, yes it gave up enough acc to cap acc easily enough with minimal gear, and thus up our atk with food enough to compete damage wise. With similarly geared players and jobs, 1h or 2h, before this update, I'd see nearly identical numbers. The elite geared 1h still beat AH 2h, the well geared 2h beat gimpy 1h, and there honestly wasn't a lot of reason to mess with it apart from adjusting SAM. But I guess when SE "fixes" something, 4-5 other things get "fixed" as well.