Crafting Sticky

[baudelaire]

The advanced player forum has a sticky "Meat vs. Sushi / War vs. Mnk vs. Nin / CoP vs ToAU / DRK"... in the week or so that I've been hanging around this crafting forum, I've seen maybe a half dozen posts that were either redundant, asked questions about myths, or other assorted nonsense.

Would it make sense to have a sticky such as the one in the advanced player forum that would address these issues and reference previous threads in a way that would alleviate some of this nonsense?

(Of course, sometimes nonsense can be a fun way to liven things up... and it's not like people who ask such mindless questions would be likely to check the sticky first... Meh... )

[baudelaire]

Persuant to the above, I've started going back through the 20 pages of this forum's history and compiling some notes:

http://wiki.bluegartr.com/User:Baudelaire/Crafting

Once I've gone through them all, I'll post it in a usable format with lots of cross-links to the bgwiki, and y'all can decide whether it's sticky-worthy.

[Tomiko]

I don't think having a sticky would make a huge difference considering this section is generally slow when it comes to new topics and usually only gets busy with updates containing new recipes and such.

Basically if they can't scroll down to at least the bottom of page 1 to check for a topic, chances are they won't check a sticky either. Regardless, it won't hurt anything if it is made. Main thing would be to make sure things are noted as being either fact (Must be within 15 levels), theory (I won't even say it), generally accepted (Tiers), etc.