I suspect that you will get the demotion message again tomorrow. Question is, will one OP tomorrow get you back to the "pleased with work, but no promotion" evaluation? If so, that helps to nail down what your daily Campaign requirment is to keep your rank. If not, that means that 260xp/820an per day isn't enough to keep you afloat at HolyKnight rank.Originally Posted by Darte
XI Wiki

When y-[n*(30-r)] ? z, you qualify for your next rank.
The point is, an elaborate system such as the latter makes no sense. You are talking about developers that made only one set of flags for outpost teleports so they have to reset them when you change nations because a seperate set of outpost supply run flags doesn't exist for each nation. The easiest route would be just to exclude XP all together and make it a simple formula with AN. This would eliminate the need for a complex process of eliminating the accumulation of points elsewhere requiring more recorded values per character to calculate something that can simply be done just using a set of numbers that only exists within the campaign system and that's Allied Notes.
For the record, I made those formulas up to prove a point that there would have to be more variables if you were to include XP and that adds up to more data per character and on a game as big as this it would be ideal to keep it as simple as possible. This is simply to illustrate a point that superfluous character data would be required to include XP as part of the solution for ranking up. That doesn't mean SE didn't go out on a limb and do such a thing, I just think that simplicity makes more sense in this case, and it is my THEORY that SE kept it simple.