Item Search
     
BG-Wiki Search
Page 6 of 7 FirstFirst ... 4 5 6 7 LastLast
Results 101 to 120 of 128

Thread: Rank Up Requirements     submit to reddit submit to twitter

  1. #101
    Hydra
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    103
    BG Level
    3

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Quote Originally Posted by Darte
    Just checked now after a few days, and got demotion message.


    Did 1 streetsweeper III for 260 xp and 820 notes and checked again and i got "Pleased with work but not enough for promo"
    I suspect that you will get the demotion message again tomorrow. Question is, will one OP tomorrow get you back to the "pleased with work, but no promotion" evaluation? If so, that helps to nail down what your daily Campaign requirment is to keep your rank. If not, that means that 260xp/820an per day isn't enough to keep you afloat at HolyKnight rank.

  2. #102
    Wincest Princess
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    591
    BG Level
    5
    FFXI Server
    Odin

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Yeah I think that pretty much confirms that there's some kind of expectation for each day that goes by for participation in campaign battles and ops. I think another important thing to clarify is if XP and AN both play a role in this and if either has more influence. To elaborate on what I was saying before about XP was that I don't think SE made an elaborate system that seperates XP gain from within campaign battles and ops as opposed to outside campaigns.

    Ryushii says he's a bit puzzled as to why I use that as a basis for my theory that XP isn't used to calculate ranking so let me break it down a little.

    You kill a monster outside of campain without allied tags etc etc, you'll get experience points but you won't get allied notes. Allied notes can ONLY (currently) be obtained via campaign battles, ops, and possibly quests to be introduced soon, but needless to say you just can't go out and farm/xp and get notes.

    That being said I don't think the system for ranking up is complicated enough to ONLY include XP from campaign ops and campaign battles. In reality, I don't think experience points at all needs to even really be a factor. There's really no reason to have both of these numbers influence ranking. It would just be simpler for SE to go with AN as that's completely proprietary to campaign battles and ops. If XP were a factor, they'd have to exclude XP that you gain in other parts of the WotG areas as well as other parts of the world for that matter.

    I think Ryushii's trying to say that "well they can just count the experience points from campaign battles and ops". But that itself would be a pretty elaborate system and in reality it wouldn't even be necessary.

    It would just be easier for SE to have
    r = days remaining on your current rank
    n = negated allied notes value per day into your current rank
    x = your total allied notes (used for making purchases and not used in determining rank)
    y = allied notes accumulated since your last rank up
    z = required value for next rank (assuming each rank requires the same number of points)

    When y-[n*(30-r)] ? z, you qualify for your next rank.


    If Xp is involved then you have something like:
    r = days that passed into your current rank
    m = negated xp value per day into your current rank
    n = negated allied notes value per day into your current rank
    v = xp accumulated since last rank up
    w = xp required for next rank
    x = your total allied notes (used for making purchases and not used in determining rank)
    y = allied notes accumulated since your next rank
    z = required value for next rank (assuming each rank requires the same number of points)

    When y-(n*r) ? z and v-(v*r) ? w you qualify for next rank.

    And that's assuming there's not a complex formula that determines a relationship between the two like

    :ashira: Rank = [y + v*.75] - r*.9[v+n] ? z+w

    On top of this you'd have to have an elaborate system that excludes XP gained outside of ops or campaign battles.

    The point is, an elaborate system such as the latter makes no sense. You are talking about developers that made only one set of flags for outpost teleports so they have to reset them when you change nations because a seperate set of outpost supply run flags doesn't exist for each nation. The easiest route would be just to exclude XP all together and make it a simple formula with AN. This would eliminate the need for a complex process of eliminating the accumulation of points elsewhere requiring more recorded values per character to calculate something that can simply be done just using a set of numbers that only exists within the campaign system and that's Allied Notes.

    For the record, I made those formulas up to prove a point that there would have to be more variables if you were to include XP and that adds up to more data per character and on a game as big as this it would be ideal to keep it as simple as possible. This is simply to illustrate a point that superfluous character data would be required to include XP as part of the solution for ranking up. That doesn't mean SE didn't go out on a limb and do such a thing, I just think that simplicity makes more sense in this case, and it is my THEORY that SE kept it simple.

    While I don't believe my first formula being anything close to accurate, I do believe the only variables used (for the sake of simplicity) are the following.
    • d The duration remaining on the medal which would be used to calculate how much AN you should have earned for the evaluation you are having
      a The number allied notes you've accumulated since you last ranked up
      e A fixed value that's probably multiplied by the number of days that has passed to assume how many points allied notes you were expected to have earned per day.
      x The value you need to earn to rank up. At first I thought this might be a fixed value, but I doubt it, as seeing that higher tier campaign ops reward more and you just tend to get more from campaigns with a higher rank. While we see 4 ranks per set of ribbons stars emblems etc, the system itself probably just sees you as rank 11 or rank 12 and that value is probably multiplied by a fixed number and added to the total needed to rank up. An example would be n*r + x where n is the factored increase per rank, and r is the rank which is added to x which is the fixed value required to rank from the start.


    If that were the case, the formula would be something as simple as:

    a - [e*(30-d)] ? x+n*r

    So, let's say we earned 8,000 allied notes. Let's say SE expects us to earn 500 a day and only 5 days have passed. 8,000-2,500 = 5,500

    5,500 ? x+n*r

    Let's now say that you are expected to earn a base value of 3,000 plus your current rank times 250 (the assumed fixed amount needed per rank in this illustration). we'll also assume you are rank 6 or Star §§.

    5,500 ? 3,000 + 250*6
    5,500 ? 3,000 + 1,500
    5,500 ? 4,500

    Since 5,500 is greater than 4,500 you rank up.

    Assuming that formula is even close to true, all you'd have to do is figure out what the variables are equal to. The numbers 3,000 for x, 500 for e and 250 for n I made up simply for illustration.

    The point is, this is the simplest formula I can think of that requires the smallest number of variables for considering rank up and I believe that simplicity would be the best way to go from a development perspective. I know I left out demotion and keeping the same rank but that would have made this illustration more complex. I'm sure demotion is having a value of less than what's expected and promotion is having the value exceeded by a specific fixed value that's added to the "required" side of the formula.

  3. #103
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    370
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Ragnarok

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Just wanted to confirm.

    These past two days from my last post, i did not campaign at all.

    After 1st day i got demotion message again. Did 1 op and got neutral message.

    Same thing for the 2nd day, demotion but 1 op later i'm on neutral.

    So really campaign ops are mainly used to combat the natural decay on campaign rank.

  4. #104
    Hydra
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    103
    BG Level
    3

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Thanks Darte. If you keep checking you can nail it down even further, but seems like you are right about an OP a day keeping demotion away. Another thing you can do is get evaluated after you get the XP for your OP but before you get the AN reward. See for sure if it is the XP or AN that is changing your evaluation status.

    Was it the same OP you did both times? You could also do a small campaign battle for 260XP/130AN and see if that does the trick.

    I am ready for Holy Knight evaluation too, but haven't done any Campaign since my last promotion. I'll post when I get some data.

  5. #105
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    370
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Ragnarok

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    That'll be a little tricky but i'll try and see what i can do.

    Edit: Yea i also did the same op. Street sweeper III

    Couldn't be bothered to try and fail the much random supply manufacture ones.

  6. #106
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    545
    BG Level
    5

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Quote Originally Posted by Gaea
    Uber long post I stopped reading halfway through.
    My point was simply that a lot of people have said how ops seem to have a minimal effect compared to campaign battles in the rank up formula. If AN were in fact the factor, than 2 ops would easily outweigh a 3k xp campaign. Also, people who spam ops alongside campaign tend to have higher xp/an totals than those who do only campaign. Then again, the proof for this lies in a lot of general comments, and nothing terribly solid, so you can't prove the point either way. Also, I'm ignoring your comment about experience points in parties, because it makes no sense whatsoever.

  7. #107
    Wincest Princess
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    591
    BG Level
    5
    FFXI Server
    Odin

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    The point about experience points in parties is to show that experience points is generally a universal thing. Meaning, that for XP to count in campaign there would have to be a second hidden XP accumulation system that ignores experienced gained from any other aspect of the game. Because Allied Notes is exclusive to the campaign system, it would just be simpler from a development perspective for XP not to be a factor at all. While it makes sense for XP to be an anticipated byproduct of campaign participation, I don't believe there's a separate behind-the-scenes system that ignores XP in every area accept Campaign.

    There's also the possibility that everyone is wrong and the system is similar to assault and its 25 point system.

    Example:
    5 points for "new campaign op"
    1 point for repeats

    5 points for campaign for over 1000 notes

    1 point for campaign wave under 1000 notes.


    Again, just a random theory. Althought, the above theory would explain why campaign battles seem to reward more. Most campaign ops that people do are repeats. Personally, I just think SE needs to come out and explain the damn system a little better. Perhaps give us more messages from the Evaluation guy to gage our progress.

  8. #108
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    545
    BG Level
    5

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Quote Originally Posted by Gaea
    Again, just a random theory. Althought, the above theory would explain why campaign battles seem to reward more. Most campaign ops that people do are repeats. Personally, I just think SE needs to come out and explain the damn system a little better. Perhaps give us more messages from the Evaluation guy to gage our progress.
    Or more than 5 people need to test the rank up requirements in a controlled environment.

  9. #109
    Wincest Princess
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    591
    BG Level
    5
    FFXI Server
    Odin

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Yeah, I think the first thing everyone needs to do is figure out what the factors for ranking up are from both campaign ops and campaign battles. We're not going to figure out anything if we don't know what numbers we are supposed to be looking at.

    One thing I'd like to suggest if anyone's getting into campaign for the first time and if you have several uncompleted campaign ops, try completing unique campaign ops until you rank up.

    Then try to repeat the action with a repeatable campaign op and see if it takes significantly longer, regardless of the allied notes you accumulate. This could appoint to an assault style point system.

    Since there are 30 days in the medal expiration, each passing day may require something like 1 point (notice there's a FIVE day delay between evaluations leaving TWENTY FIVE days left if you do an evaluation at that point. These are both values used in the assault style system. Campaign battles may just add points based on specific thresholds like <500 = 1pt 500-1000= 2pt, etc.

    But again, just another whacky theory illustrating the point that the first thing we need to do is fine out what the factors for determining rank are and then go about quantity. I can test the thing with "new campaign ops" after the update probably. I have been unable to do several ops due to the fact it's like impossible to lose a region to beastmen and several ops require that you do something in "beastmen controlled territory".

  10. #110
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    370
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Ragnarok

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    udpdate:

    waited until i got demotion, then got into a small 300 xp 400 allied note battle, checked and i was on neutral again.

    Edit: won't be able to provide anymore testing, was down to last day so i had to accept so i could start getting enough for promo upon update.

  11. #111
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    545
    BG Level
    5

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Quote Originally Posted by Darte
    udpdate:

    waited until i got demotion, then got into a small 300 xp 400 allied note battle, checked and i was on neutral again.

    Edit: won't be able to provide anymore testing, was down to last day so i had to accept so i could start getting enough for promo upon update.
    I'm currently in the middle of a test like this, I'll post results in a week or so.

  12. #112
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    370
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Ragnarok

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Small theory: The higher your rank, the bigger the decay. Particularly, the decay rate is roughly equivalent to the average xp reward of the highest tiered ops you can access at your rank. Would make sense no?

  13. #113
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    545
    BG Level
    5

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Quote Originally Posted by Darte
    Small theory: The higher your rank, the bigger the decay. Particularly, the decay rate is roughly equivalent to the average xp reward of the highest tiered ops you can access at your rank. Would make sense no?
    Makes sense, and chances are it's some sort of small percentage of the actual requirement for ranking up, thereby making it self-increasing.

  14. #114
    Wincest Princess
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    591
    BG Level
    5
    FFXI Server
    Odin

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    I'm on the fence about there being an actual decay. I think that its actually related to the number of days that have passed since your next evaluation. Example:


    Only 5 days passed (getting evaluation asap): requires a amount of whatever the factors are for ranking up.
    6 days passed. requires b amount (slightly higher than a amount)
    7 days past. requires c amount. (slightly higher than b amount)........

    .............and so forth and so forth.

    I think the formula for this is something closer to:
    (30-x)*y
    Where x is the number of days remaining in your duration and y is equal to the average amount they expect you to earn for each day past. This number likely increases as rank increases.

    The effect this formula has would be perceived as decay, but I don't think anythign is actually decaying as in "going down in value". I just think the expected value for you to earn to rank up increases on a daily basis. And the factor that it increases by is higher with each rank.

    Example of this formula put to work would be:
    (30-22)*y (assuming you have 22 days left on yoru medal)
    8*y (the amount of allied notes or whatever it is they use to determine rank up they expect you to get)
    If y = 500 for "Ribbons" rank.

    Then 8*500 = 4000

    In this example 4000 allied notes or whatever it is that determines rank up would be the requirement to rank up 8 days after your last evaluation.

  15. #115
    Relic Weapons
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    370
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Ragnarok

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    While i can't go as far as 5-6 days, i did wait 2 days before checking eval for a demotion. Had 2 op credits at that time, had to do both to be neutral again.

  16. #116
    Banned.
    Account locked at request of user.

    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Posts
    9,841
    BG Level
    8

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Day 28 promotion to Iron Emblem took 18k EXP.

  17. #117
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    545
    BG Level
    5

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Quote Originally Posted by Gaea
    I'm on the fence about there being an actual decay. I think that its actually related to the number of days that have passed since your next evaluation.
    I agree, a lot of people seem to need more xp/an to rank up when they are several days late in getting their rank up. If your points decayed, then starting to work on points on day 18 would require the same amount as day 5, which isn't true. It's definately some sort of increase in the requirement, not decrease in your point total.

  18. #118
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    545
    BG Level
    5

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    Here's a claim I want to prove based on some evidence of mine in the other thread:

    Rank up is not determined solely by AN accrued
    I did a rank up from Emblem I>II. The totals at the end were 10420 XP 15217 AN 25637 combined. I ranked up on Day 9.
    I did a rank up from Emblem II>III. The totals at the end were 11125 XP 8087 AN 19212 combined. I ranked up on Day 10.

    We know there is some sort of deterioration rate of some sort. Based on testing done by BRP and myself, we know it is some number below 1000XP/500AN. We also know that higher ranks require higher amount of XP/AN.

    To prove this, we have to make the following assumptions:
    Rank up requirements are constant, and increase in higher ranks.
    They are based on some sort of system related to points acquired.
    The rate of deterioration is generally constant, and is below 1000xp/500an
    Points from campaign ops factor in the same as points from campaign battles.

    The first we have to believe if we want to figure this out. If we don't believe the second, then this test is pointless. The third is a bit more difficult to assume, but whether it is based on a percentage or a constant, it is doubtful the number would ever rise above the number given above based on the test we have conducted. The fourth is the only assumption we cannot truly make, but we know ops factor in somehow, so unless the system is not based on points, ops are most likely calculated into effect the same way as battles.

    Now that the assumptions/conditions are met, here is how my understanding of our current theory of ranking up is:

    Day 5: xxxxx XP or AN or combined required for rank up.
    Day 6: xxxxx + X XP or AN or combined required for rank up.
    Day 7: xxxxx + X + X XP or AN or combined required for rank up.

    Thus if a point value of 10420 XP 15217 AN 25637 combined is higher than the value required for a Day 9 evaluation at Emblem I, then we know that our total minus 1605 XP 1874 AN 3479 combined is below that value. We do not know how far below it is, so we have to assume it could be as close as 1 point below, or as far as 1604 XP 1873 AN 3478 combined below. Let us assume it is the latter. That would mean our lowest possible value would be 8816 XP 13344 AN 22159 combined for rank up on Day 9 of Emblem I.

    Looking out our other test, we see a total of 11125 XP 8087 AN 19212 combined. This is both a farther day away from rank up and on a higher rank. From our assumptions earlier, that means that our total should be higher than the value of ranking up on in earlier day OR on an earlier rank. We have our lowest possible value for ranking up both a day earlier and a rank earlier set at 8816 XP 13344 AN 22159 combined. Both the AN total and the combined total are higher than our totals for the Emblem II test. Therefore either the theory that requirements increase in higher days and higher ranks or the theory that AN or the combined total of points determines rank up is wrong.

    Conclusion: We have no reason to disbelieve our theory that requirements increase in higher ranks or higher days. At the very least we can agree that in increase in either would not cause a decrease in requirements, which would have to be true in order for this test to not condemn AN or combined totals as the rank up factor. The only other possibility is that another one of our assumptions is false.

    Here are our assumptions again:
    Rank up requirements are constant, and increase in higher ranks.
    They are based on some sort of system related to points acquired.
    The rate of deterioration is generally constant, and is below 1000xp/500an
    Points from campaign ops factor in the same as points from campaign battles.

    We have no reason to disbelieve the first assumption. The second is up for grabs, but again this test is pointless if we try to call it false. The third presents a problem, however. There is certainly some sort of deterioration rate, but it could either be some sort of constant or some sort of percent decrease per day. I'm am currently testing this theory.

    The last possibility is that ops do not factor the same way. We know they factor somehow, because people have ranked up and kept ranks doing ops. If we are making the second assumption, however, that means that the points contributed by ops do something. Honestly, other than contributing normally, I see no other way of ops contributing.

    Real Conclusion Either AN/combined point values do not effect rank ups, or the deterioration rate is extremely twisted, or ops have a very odd effect on rank ups. The third is highly unlikely, simply because nothing else than what we currently have makes sense. At the risk of making an error, I am going to accept that ops are normal. It is extremely doubtful that the deterioration rate would be so odd as to create a the 5000+ gap we saw in the experiment. It could potentially have created the nearly 3000 gap between the combined totals, but the two tests were very similar in point obtaining, so any of the current plausible theories concerning point deterioration could account for the AN discrepancy.

    Long story short, AN is not the deciding factor for ranking up.
    A combination of experience points and AN may or may not be the/a factor. Further testing is needed to disprove the second theory.

  19. #119
    House Azazael
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    1,641
    BG Level
    6
    FFXI Server
    Fenrir

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    I would need to double check my file for confirmation on this, but I just ranked up to Sterling Star ?? doing nothing but street sweeper II. I might have done one campaign somewhere in the last week (though again I don't think I did), but I know that I did 13 Street Sweeper II and 1 Street Sweeper 1.

  20. #120
    Always Cabrón!
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    463
    BG Level
    4
    FFXIV Character
    Lor'enzo Sasha
    FFXIV Server
    Hyperion
    FFXI Server
    Odin

    Re: Rank Up Requirements

    As a crude test I checked my AN only on the day I had been promoted to Steel Knight Emblem §§§
    I had approx of 65500.
    I proceeded to do Campaign Battles and Campaign Ops until I had accrued 5000 more Alliance Notes.
    On the 2nd day after SKEmbem§§§ I had accrued approximately of 70500 AN.
    I did nothing for the remainder of the 5 "grace" days where I could not be evaluated.
    On evaluation day, I received a 'enough to stay at rank, not enough to promote'
    I did 1 Campaign Battle and 1 Campaign Op (Aegis Shield I) adding a little under 1k more Alliance notes.
    Total there was approximately 71500.
    One more Battle and another (Aegis Shield I) Op, brought my total to approx 72500.
    Checked with evaluator and was awarded Holy Knight Emblem §§§§.

    I'd like to go out on a limb and quote a minimum value of Alliance notes I've needed for "5th day" evaluation success escalates between 5k~7k.
    But I cannot confirm, since there are currently 11 successful promotions available (ribbon 1 is awarded on joining a national army) and the math does not add up by just using my personal observation (not proper experimentation nor proper record keeping).

Page 6 of 7 FirstFirst ... 4 5 6 7 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Nyzul Rank Up Points
    By LordMagnus in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 2007-08-30, 13:10
  2. 1stLt Rank Up Quest
    By Ruin in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 14
    Last Post: 2007-08-29, 13:48
  3. Do Excess Assault rank up points carry over?
    By Loziel in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 2007-08-10, 08:26
  4. Assault rank up glitch?
    By VZX in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 22
    Last Post: 2007-06-27, 13:47
  5. CM Rank Up Quest
    By sahearniitth in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 2007-03-10, 22:13
  6. Chief Sergeant Rank Up
    By Brandson in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 2007-03-08, 09:16
  7. SM rank up quest
    By Luftiig in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 2007-02-15, 05:16
  8. Assault - Confirm Rank-Up Requirements?
    By Kyomu in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 177
    Last Post: 2006-06-27, 17:49