1 Str 5 Att for 150-190k in a slot with maybe three better options all ranging from half a mil to multi-millions is a pretty good way to spend money.
It's like saying "Well, Haubergeon only has 10 Accuracy and Attack over Sipahi body, why bother?"
Because the Haubergeon is a keystone piece which will be acceptable for as long as you have it, with nearly any other gear attached.
I don't think the issue is people who are scrimping and saving gil to get stuff though (btw, I farmed up something like 2 million gil a few weeks back just watching TV and mindlessly killing Bugards/Ladybugs because I felt like getting some pretty unicorn gear, I know for a fact you can make better returns for the time with a variety of other things, with lower level jobs even) it's people who have stuff like... big ticket abjuration pieces uncursed, PCC's, big ticket weapons... and NQ amemet.
Is a woodsman ring a better use of 100-200k than NQ > HQ amemet? Yes, yes it is.
Is a Juggernaut a better use of gil?
No.
XI Wiki

