
Originally Posted by
riddaraan
Since this has turned into a "crime & punishment" debate, I just wanted to throw out my thought, and see if anyone bites.
Basically, the reason that so many underground, illegal guns are purchased, is because often times, petty criminals (who get caught in stings) wind up belly flopping for the cops, so that the police can go after bigger fish. And on and on it goes, until they find the "source" of the problem. It's much like this in the way of drugs, so we'd have to assume it to be true with guns as well.
However, by doing the catch & release method on small time offenders, you allow them to wander back into civilization, without rehabilitation, to perpetuate the growth of the cancer. Unfortunately, by the time the police actually manage to wrangle anyone of any importance, it's too late, and some small fish has grown large and fat, and replaces the fallen emperor of evil.
Obviously, this means that a majority of our crime problems, including gun control, are based upon the failed tactics of our law-enforcement and criminal justice systems. Before we start barging into legislation and pointing fingers, I think we should take a deeper look and evaluate the failure of the core of our judicial system.
Even if you cut down the giant tree, you still have the millions of roots in your yard.
I believe in enforcing stronger penalties for small time criminals. However, I also believe in re-defining what "small time criminal" means. Busting a guy for a dime sack, and throwing him in the slammer isn't right, especially when a hidden majority of the population partakes in the herb.
But catch a guy with an illegal gun just once? Let's talk about cruel & inhumane.