Originally Posted by Metah
After reading the other thread when the movie first came out I went and got the book. Unless the copy I found was edited or something was wrong with it I hated the book, was too short, and I think the ending sucked horribly.
The book had him dying at the end?(if I remember, read it a few months ago, and I read a lot of books) I don't really see how it correlates with the book much either.
I do think though that some movies need to have the whole sad element/ending to them sometimes, two movies I use as a basis for saying this are The Butterfly Effect(the directors cut version) and The Guardian, both of which are two of my all time favorite movies, and the endings are for a lack of better words just plain sad.
XI Wiki

