In terms of Rogue (you wrote Rouge, but I'm assuming you meant Rogue), the flavor did not sit well with me at all. It's a bit amateurish for my tastes. They're still a young brewery, relatively, so they will more than likely improve.
Brooklyn, just no. Their line of beers have been crazily overhyped in the markets here. They have cases of it stacked up everywhere (along with that new Margaritaville lager beer). I expected it to be a lot more than it is.
Smuttynose comes off with a "micro breweryness" about it. Not my style at all.