
Originally Posted by
Fornax
I must defend Wopa here. His achievement is substantial. He got a large group of people to join what is essentially a private Tiamat farming static for his personal benefit and has them believe they are in an HNM linkshell. These players sacrifice their playtime to monopolize gaiters for him and acquiesce to him retaining a disproportional share of the profit while he doesn't even camp.
Making an arrangement like that work takes considerable psychological skill and insight into player motivation. How do you acquire and retain the indispensable PLDs for example? Wopa's solution is brilliant - monopolize Khimaira in addition to Timmy. Exclusive server control of Khim means you'll have an endless supply of PLDs who can't wait to camp Timmy for you in the uncertain hope that you'll let them lot a Hauteclaire some day.
This subtle but effective member control mechanism is aided and enabled by a designed total absence of point system, charter, lotting rules or any other kind of mechanism by which members could hold their leader accountable. Item and gil rewards are granted or withheld indefinitely solely at the leader's discretion, creating an environment where members must compete for the leader's personal favor. As in all types of societies ruled by the whims of an all-powerful leader, expression of dissent or dissatisfaction over loot distribution tends to be rare.
The design of this power structure is elegant and sophisticated as it involves no apparent coercion of members. Indeed, the linkshell name leaves no doubt as to the priorities of the group and the identity of the primary beneficiary of all linkshell activity. No member can claim to be unaware of the nature of the group.
A naive observer might expect such a group to disintegrate within a very short period of time. Members who perceive that the leader enriches himself at their expense would tend to leave quickly. Indeed, it takes a delicate touch to find just the right balance of withholding and granting rewards so that average member time to burnout is reduced to the level needed where personnel attrition and recruitment are in equilibrium.
Wopa deserves praise for recognizing and acting on the critical need to recruit members from other servers once he had approached the point where he had burnt through most server natives. Cross-server recruitment opened up an almost limitless labor pool that was largely unexposed to negative word of mouth and easily impressed by Pravda-style front pages and linkshell loot lists inflated by counting items recruits acquired outside the linkshell.
Wopadobop is well on track to be the first and only player in FFXI to own all 16 relics. He has created a unique and highly effective support structure to finance this project. I applaud him for this singular achievement.