Fantasy Football: Play 'em or Bench 'em Discussion!

[Brill Weave]

Toss out White and try to snake out one of his receivers instead and I would take that deal. I'm fucked right now on my running back situation. I'm sitting on Forte, Grant, and McGahee. Starting Forte is a given since he's the only back I have who's actually healthy. Probably going to start Grant over McGahee.

[archibaldcrane]

It looks like you need Frank Gore much more than you need Romo. That being said, you're going to probably end up cutting or being forced to trade away one of your 6 RBs if you do this trade. Can you get something else instead of White - a 3rd WR or something?

Edit: What the fuck Brill get out of my head.

[Fistandantilus]

I'd say do it for sure, having Gore and Addai will be beastly and you still have Cutler who so far has been spectacular.

[Kurp]

Reggie Bush, Felix Jones, Ryan Grant, or Darren McFadden

I can start two and I'm pretty set on using Reggie Bush. I'm leaning towards McFadden for the second, but I can't decide.

[Tyr]

Reggie Bush, Felix Jones, Ryan Grant, or Darren McFadden

I can start two and I'm pretty set on using Reggie Bush. I'm leaning towards McFadden for the second, but I can't decide.

I would start McFadden or Jones this week over Grant, because he's still injured and he's going to play the Dallas unit that didn't give that much space to Westbrook. I think Jones will give you more expected numbers (something like 60 yards rushing and some return yards), while McFadden can either play poorly (like 40 yards and a fumble) or just break out again (100+ yards and a score), but it depends on the severity of his injury. Still, he's got a hot hand, Fargas is out, I'd go with McFadden.

[Plow]

You can't not start Peyton.

This should be in the OP or something, people have asked Peyton questions twice now, wtf!


Hell maybe it should just be the name of the thread

[Daahan]

Holy shit Reggie Bush has been PRODUCING

[Mizango]

Holy shit Reggie Bush has been PRODUCING

Big time.

[Daahan]

I accepted the trade so with Addai, Gore, and Bush I'm solid at RB now. I'm going to try to trade for a good WR now.

[Fistandantilus]

Peyton with 8 FFL points for me atm

[Akiyama]

Big drive there by Peyton though.

[wyrmtung]

Hurray for SD for running up the score and kicking unnecessary 49 yard FGs with 2 mins left in the game. I had Kaeding kicking for me and down by 8. I went from a nail biter going into the game to an easy win at the end of the game.

Kinda makes up for me losing by one point last week from Desean Jackson's dumb ass. Kinda but not really.

[Deejay]

I was happy as hell to see the Chargers still passing when they were up 20 in the 3rd lol. I was down like 16 or so points with Rivers/Cotcerry vs. Darren Sproles.

Game turned out perfectly for me.

[Gregorio]

What do you guys think of this trade I'm workin on...

Welker, Coles, and Andre Hall for McNabb and Owens. Also probably proposing the same trade with Sammy Morris instead of Hall.

The other guy has Westbrook and McFadden then not much depth at RB. McNabb is one of his backups...and would be mine behind Peyton. I have Matt Ryan currently as my backup, I'd most likely drop him. Plus Westbrook is (possibly) injured. The guy disconnected mid-way through the draft so he ended up with 4 QBs on his team cause his value picks were messed up (which he still hasn't been able to fix yet).

[Akiyama]

If you can get McNabb and Owens for an overrated Welker (he's overrated now anyway), Coles (who had a TD finally tonight), and Hall/Morris... then more power to you. There's no way in hell I'd do that trade though. Hall plays for Denver. You NEVER know who is going to get more touches in a Shanahan scheme. Morris did pretty shitty against the Dolphins and will be splitting time with LaMont Jordan and Maroney (when he comes back).

[Gregorio]

Yeah I would definitely make out awesome in that trade. He has Aaron Rogers starting most of the time and also has lolVinceYoung and lolHasselback on his team, so I figure he would't miss McNabb terribly. I just want a real number 1 receiver (Got Jennings, Reggie Brown and DeShaun Jackson aside from the ones I'm attempting to trade). I'm hoping he feels like he has to trade for them because his depth at RB and receiver are terrible. One for 3 ain't such a bad deal.

[Akiyama]

If he was smart, he'd deal the previous two backups he's got and oh.. I dunno, start McNabb over Rodgers? lol. Jennings and DeSean aren't bad. At least you have one #1 WR. DeSean is a decent #2. If you get that trade off, then good for you.

[Gregorio]

If he was smart, he'd deal the previous two backups he's got and oh.. I dunno, start McNabb over Rodgers? lol. Jennings and DeSean aren't bad. At least you have one #1 WR. DeSean is a decent #2. If you get that trade off, then good for you.

In our league Rogers has actually out scored McNabb 2 out of 3 weeks. Week 1 McNabb only scored 4 more points than Rogers too. Plus McNabb is inconsistant and injury prone...and this is coming from an Eagles fan. DeSean is pretty good and a decent number 2 for now, but I'm skeptical how his numbers will be when Curtis and Brown and fully back in action, especially knowing how McNabb and Reid like to spread the ball around.

And actually even though the other guys QB play has worked out (he started McNabb the only week he outscored Rogers), he's not such a great fantasy player so I'm hoping he goes for it. :D

[Akiyama]

True, but look at the difference in competition. Rodgers had the Vikings (weak pass defense), Favre had the Rams. So cancel those out. Rodgers had the Lions, McNabb had the Cowboys. Throw out the Lions, and McNabb did decent against the 'boys. Granted I had an argument about McNabb, and no way his three WRs would get over 100+, etc, but he still had an alright game against a good team. Week 3 put Rodgers against that same Dallas defense, while McNabb got a tough Pittsburgh team, so really... I'd probably be starting McNabb. They should be getting Reggie Brown back, and Kevin Curtis in a few more weeks.

I wish I was in your league. =[

[Edgie]

Alright its early but w.e, Torry holt @ buffalo or Derrick mason @ pittsburg