
Originally Posted by
Drex
Well if we're going to play extremes, then are you arguing that rich people shouldn't pay any taxes and the middle class should be thrown into slavery?
No one's saying "taek all their moniez", but we have a huge deficit and are in dire need of reform in a number of fields. It's going to cost money, and we can't just keep taking out loans to do it. Leaving things as they are is not an option, and taxing the struggling middle class more is not an option.
The wealthy have, in one way or another, benefited from the American system more than the middle class. They are being rewarded for their hard work with money and financial security (if they aren't dumb with it, anyway...). No one is suggesting that we should tax them until they drop to the middle class. Removal of a tax cut is not going to suddenly take your mansion and revert it to a 2 bedroom-2 bath, nor is it going to rip the engine out of your sports car. You *should* feel obligated to give back to the system that allowed you to thrive in the first place. It's how America was meant to work.
I'm not advocating pure socialism, gogoMarx, etc, but pure capitalism doesn't work either. You need a balance, and the country as it stands now needs money. The country put you in a position to make the money you have now, and now, when it needs your help, you won't give a little more back? That is greed.