a) Ignorance (same reason your friend thinks provoke is awesome)
b) Used to it (same reason a lot of LSes still use PLD/WAR by default for everything)
c) Most RDMs don't have top of the line tanking sets, while most PLDs and NINs do. A very well geared PLD/NIN will do far better than a poorly geared RDM/NIN
d) Most RDMs don't know how to tank, and many don't care to learn. My LS has tons of RDMs, but I am the only one that tanks anything. None of the others have ever expressed an interest in trying it.
e) Most linkshells don't want to bring an alliance of RDMs to every fight. Some linkshells just don't have enough RDMs to afford to have 2 tanking, plus one as support in each party at every event
g) NINs and PLDs don't really have any other role in HNM fights (unless they have relic I guess), while there's plenty of things you can do with a RDM (healer, supporter, enfeebling, I guess lolnuking if you had to)
RDM is awesome at building long term hate, but for series of short fights (like dynamis, limbus, einherjar, etc.) PLD/WAR will do better if you want a pure tank. Of course then you could argue for DD tanking which is another can of worms...
XI Wiki



