Most Paladin's don't own Crimson or Blood Scale Mail, a hefty amount of them don't own Valor Leggings, and there's nothing intelligent about switching out your weapon every time you go to cast Stoneskin, never mind the fact that you lose Shield Mastery, and all hope of getting it up by doing so.
You mean on mobs where you won't be meleeing anyway? Ouryu? JOL?
If you're bloodtanking anything else meleeable, just don't switch your weapon if you need your TP.
You can get 42 MND out of that gear without Crimson Scale Mail. There's Communion Earrings, etc. that I skipped over, I just named some of the cheapest AHable stuff at random.
And you can modify your windower macros to have your shield skill gear on for ~5 seconds of the cast, then throw on the MND gear before Stoneskin finishes casting, if you're afraid of getting interrupted, etc., but who bothers with stoneskin while bloodtanking unless your co-tank has hate or it's between mobs?
Shit is situational?
This thread really has nothing to do with JoL or Ouryu. The two fights are complete oddities, and aren't even remotely similar to anything else.
Situational is a bit of a broad statement when we're literally talking about 1% of the game's fights.
And how many fights would a PLD be /RDM and casting Stoneskin anyway? 1%! We're going in circles here.
My initial response was just mentioning that a PLD CAN cap Stoneskin with easy-to-obtain gear, but even the usage of it is limited anyways, not to mention PLD/RDM in itself is limited by purpose and application. This is where your "1% of the game's fights" fall in.
I also addressed the situations where a PLD could use Stoneskin and not get interrupted to hell (usually mobs where you dont even melee them, or they aren't meleeing you half the time, ie. JOL or Ouryu, etc.), and the rest of the time it's between mobs in Dyna or something.
You mentioned that you shouldn't macro out your weapon and lose TP. I did say, "mix and match what you can acquire" and I figured with the relative intelligence of these boards, I didn't need to mention "oh, and if you need your TP, don't switch your weapon." It's pretty common knowledge, I'd think.
We're saying the same thing, and arguing just to be arguing.
Hey there, Asura i was hoping you might be able to solve a friendly dispute between two friends of mine discussing the whole fact of rdm tank vs. pld tank. OK the question that kept coming up is HNM tanking/long tanks. When you go co-tanking, do you have another tank with you to back you up when your shadows go down? Also, does the rdm medigation solely come from stoneskin and phalanx and whats the ratio/comparison between the two and also how that affects pld tank to give rdm have an edge?
I generally don't need help tanking most things, but even when you're not fighting something that resets hate(in which case, having two tanks is pretty 'duh'), shit can always go wrong at inopportune times. Even if everyone I co-tank with can't keep up with my enmity, its always nice to have them around for those 'just in case' moments. So to answer your question, no, I never really have anyone there to help me when shadows go down, because they're generally not anywhere near I am as far as our target's attention span is concerned. On the flip-side, though, my shadows are hardly ever down, so its not a big deal ;p
As for the damage mitigation bit, absolutely not. I take significantly less physical and magical damage than any Paladin in my linkshell, two of which have Aegis, and this is before taking my 410 Stoneskin buffer into consideration. That's not to say that Paladins in general are worse at said task(truth be told, I'd say they're dead-even, before Stoneskin gets involved), I'm just a much more prepared player in general than any of our tanks, be it because they simply don't give a damn, or because I'm just better at the job.
Not that I disagree with the concept, as I idle in as much Acc gear as I can manage...but wouldn't Joyeuse + Atonement be much better both DD and enmity-wise than Haute + Spirits?
And regarding PLD vs. RDM...I have both, I'm biased towards using my own RDM vs. my own PLD since my RDM gear destroys my PLD gear and the length of PLD casting times kinda fuck with me after years of RDM, but personally I would prefer a well-geard PLD main tank as they can contribute to killspeed much more than a RDM(barring Excal situations), and have the ability to regain hate more quickly after a hate-reset TP move.
As for survivability, unless it's something that takes shadows extremely quickly, they're pretty much even to me between Shield vs. Stoneskin/fast casting times, and if both a RDM and a PLD are in your tank party either way the RDM can support the PLD but not vice-versa. Then again I'm used to being in small groups without excess RDMs, the only reason I even started RDM tanking was due to us being short on a 2nd reliable tank.
I consider fast cast a pretty nice form of indirect damage mitigation, since it always works. RDM's answer to shield mastery for PLD is not needing shield mastery to get spells off in the first place.
edit: RDM is a fantastic solo tank, but I prefer having a backup there for when shit hits the fan
The casting time of Ichi on PLD was a huuuuuuge fucking adjustment, the first time I went to PLD tank an event after hitting 75 I got stomped to death by Genbu because I wasn't expecting it to take 9 seconds to fire off a spell that my RDM does in 3, lol.
People bitch back and forth, but this is the only real thing I envy from a RDM tank. Ichi takes so damn long to cast as a PLD, even with Homam pants and Loq. earring. Many times while recasting it after Ni you actually have to not suck while timing it to get it to go through without needing to hope for a shield block.
That shit sucks, I want to not have to think while tanking. :-þ
The only other thing is(maybe this is just me), but RDM tanking vs. PLD for me is a fuckload more button pressing. There is pretty much no single moment that I'm not casting something...I'm always concerned that my hate is not quite capped so even a few minutes into the fight I'm typically spamming Blind after I've gone through all my Sleep/Dispel rounds a few times. I've been using sushi and going ESword/Joy lately to try and do Death Blossom > Atonement, but Tan gets TP 3x as fast as I do just because I don't have enough idle time to actually swing.
Is Death Blossom actually not garbage against HNMs? Or is it just for the Light/resistance factor?
It is in fact garbage unfortunately...being a plain-ish multi-hit you need a pretty large amount of attack and acc for it to do well, which just doesn't happen vs. high-end mobs(aside from the fact that I just can't fit my tanking and my melee gear). I only use it for the SC properties(which are absolutely fantastic) and the added effect, since I don't generally need the extra hate of Spirits Within, and the added damage from Light every 100% will outdo saving to 300% for SW.
Interesting. Mind if I inquire as to your idle setup? And how's your accuracy, generally? It sounds like a pretty solid concept if the resistance reduction is as significant as people say.
My acc isn't terrible, the main issue is hitting for 0(especially on Ultima). I have full Sword merits, use Dorado Sushi, and idle in mostly Haste:
ESword/Joy/Lamian Kaman
W.Turban
PCC(might switch to Fort when I get it)
Hollow(don't own Suppa or I'd use that)/Loq
Goliard Saio
Dusk Gloves
Rings are iffy, I'd like to use my Ecphoria+Woodsman but sometimes can't fit, so just Mermaid + BQ
Boxer's Mantle
Swift Belt
Nashira Seraweels
Dusk Ledelsens
Like I said my attack is very low since I can't fit my actual attack gear, on bigger mobs I don't think I've topped 120 with DB, but I've only really tried vs. Limbus bosses and Sky gods...I will say that usually I'm getting Hunter's Roll though, I tried Genbu this way without it and my Accuracy was actually really shitty. Without Hunter's I'd probably not bother and just do Beaver Tails or Terra's + Shark Strap. And like I said the big issue is that I cast so often that honestly there's just not enough idle time to swing with.
Bleh. We have a Corsair available once in a blue moon, guess that won't work so well for me >:
Don't feel bad, many single hander DDs have issues on Ultima, specifically hitting for 0 a shit-ton during the TP phase. Back when I first got Atonement, and I wanted to spam close Light with it, the BLU I was trying to SC with got TP about half the speed as I did, and I was in my tanking gear. >_>;;;;
Accuracy was awesome, but all I kept seeing was 0s and single digits in the log...