Item Search
     
BG-Wiki Search
Page 7 of 7 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7
Results 121 to 139 of 139

Thread: RDM Tanks?     submit to reddit submit to twitter

  1. #121
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    506
    BG Level
    5

    What I should have asked was:
    by saying tanking Byakko in damage reduction set, do you mean gearswapping less? Thinking about it, you could still swap in haste without much risk, since you'll have shadows up by the end of the cast. Or do you keep dmg reduction on even then for fear of a Cyclone before you finish casting? With hate spells do you sacrifice enmity gear by keeping slots that contain PDT-% unchanged?

  2. #122
    You just got served THE CALLISTO SPECIAL
    SASSAGE KING OF DA WORLD
    cheap hawks gay

    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    26,424
    BG Level
    10

    Regarding merits for RDM tanking, the only one that can make any real difference is Convert recast, I have 3 to shave a full minute off. You don't neccesarily need it for the MP that often if you have normal tank support, but being able to Convert and drop a few C4s on yourself helps to get hate back after a reset.

  3. #123
    rog
    rog is offline
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,874
    BG Level
    7

    Solos and tanking in groups are different, I know, but watching RDM solos with straight tanking, it usually means constant reapplying SS cus of all the hits you take. It seemed obvious to assume tanking tougher stuff with support (though easier in several ways) would result in more TP moves and so more damage taken.
    it depends on the mob's attack speed, mnd (slow/para potency), if they're immune to slow/para, and DA/TA rate.

    anything that doesn't DA/TA at all, can be tanked with just slow(2), without para, and getting hit at all (excluding spells/tp moves of course) would be fairly pathetic.

    for mobs that DA, it depends on luck. for mobs that attack at standard 180 delay, with just slow2, and no para/evade/parry procs, you can keep utsu up indefinitely as long as it doesn't DA more than i think twice, maybe 3 times per ~26 seconds.

    for mobs that attack faster than 180 delay, it depends on alot of things. rapido for example attacks alittle faster, but not only can you use wands for an extra 18~20 mnd for slow/para, it's also particularly susceptable to para. with a good slow2+para2, and especially if you engage (with ceremonial daggers obviously), then you can sometimes go 5+ mins without getting SS hit at all. even with just para1 it's not uncommon to not have ss hit for 2-3+ mins; in fact when i solo it, most of the time my ss gets hit is when it DAs when i have 1 shadow left, not because i can't keep them up, though it varies alot due evades, parries, para procs, and DAs all being random.

    with the extra 1/4 seconds off utsu1/2 from march, not to mention elegy, melee hits should basically never hit a rdm, except for obvious exceptions like byakko. obviously you'd need to recast SS after every ws that ignores/strips shadows, but other than that it really shouldn't need to be recasted that much, except for mobs that resist slow/elegy (and/or para). and besides, it's not like having to cast ss really matters much anyway...it casts less than a second slower than utsu1 does for other non-rdm jobs.

  4. #124
    New Merits
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    214
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Caitsith

    Unless the mob doubles and triple attacks ALOT or wipes shadows, i dont even bother with stoneskin at all.

  5. #125
    rog
    rog is offline
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,874
    BG Level
    7

    Quote Originally Posted by Caerloc View Post
    Unless the mob doubles and triple attacks ALOT or wipes shadows, i dont even bother with stoneskin at all.
    that's kind of stupid. not only does it save mp (~the same hp as cure4 for 29 mp), it also saves you ~500 ce, depending on max hp (more with stone gorget/mufflers), AND it also prevents interrupts. the 4.5 seconds it takes to cast it doesn't even come close to outweighing the benefits of it.

  6. #126
    Tarmo
    Guest

    Sorry I wasn't more specific on the Byakko tanking equip. For that fight I idle in -44%(-50% @ night) physical dmg, just because shadows are usually torn off. And the add effect usually does 0 even in Jelly Ring. Odd I know, but that's what happens.

  7. #127
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    4,753
    BG Level
    7

    Quote Originally Posted by Caerloc View Post
    Unless the mob doubles and triple attacks ALOT or wipes shadows, i dont even bother with stoneskin at all.
    I'll concede to the fact that with how fast we can fire off Utsusemi, its not always doing anything, but knowing any shadow-stripping AoE will likely do absolutely no damage is always nice.

  8. #128
    Formerly Raitoken
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    2,564
    BG Level
    7
    FFXI Server
    Asura
    WoW Realm
    Lightning's Blade

    Also what would be a good haste setup when a BRD is not available? Sometimes having a BRD isn't possible on every single fight or when a HNM pops in its first window and don't have the luxary of waiting for one.

    You hit the cap with BRD for Ichi and Ni recast but would it be possible without? What gear would you need to fill in that gap?

    Assume AF Hat, Duelist Body, Loq Earring, Swift belt already,...

    Also no one else has any other comments regarding sword/shield RDM with Excalibur and capped shield/parry merits?

  9. #129
    New Merits
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    214
    BG Level
    4
    FFXI Server
    Caitsith

    Quote Originally Posted by rog View Post
    that's kind of stupid. not only does it save mp (~the same hp as cure4 for 29 mp), it also saves you ~500 ce, depending on max hp (more with stone gorget/mufflers), AND it also prevents interrupts. the 4.5 seconds it takes to cast it doesn't even come close to outweighing the benefits of it.
    What does it matter when its constantly wearing without being used i wonder. Read again what i said. If the mob doesnt constantly strip my shadows or triple attack, i dont need the stoneskin. As for cures.. Generally once my CE is capped... my spellcycle consists of Blind -> Blind -> Blind -> Blind -> Blind -> Blind -> Blind -> Blind... you get the picture. Thats 5 mp per blind.. i COULD afford a cure if i needed one..

  10. #130
    rog
    rog is offline
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,874
    BG Level
    7

    Quote Originally Posted by Raitoken View Post
    Also what would be a good haste setup when a BRD is not available? Sometimes having a BRD isn't possible on every single fight or when a HNM pops in its first window and don't have the luxary of waiting for one.

    You hit the cap with BRD for Ichi and Ni recast but would it be possible without? What gear would you need to fill in that gap?

    Assume AF Hat, Duelist Body, Loq Earring, Swift belt already,...
    cap? no. you'd need ~44% haste with base fc, and loq (not including tabard/hat, because goliard/walmart are better for recasts).

    with loq, walmart, goliard, speed, nashira, dusk+1, dusk+1, and haste you get 0.4571% delay reduction, or 16.28/24.43 sec recasts. could add on sentinel shield, but i'm too lazy to find numbers with that, lol.

    a more reasonable build being nq dusk gloves, and swift belt gets you 0.4304%, 17.08/25.63 sec recasts, which is pretty close to the best possible.

  11. #131
    rog
    rog is offline
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    3,874
    BG Level
    7

    Quote Originally Posted by Raitoken View Post
    Also no one else has any other comments regarding sword/shield RDM with Excalibur and capped shield/parry merits?
    lol. rdm won't parry more than the base 5% on an hnm, and although they may get slightly higher for shield, i doubt it, and it certainly wouldn't be worth meriting, unless you also use pld. the -10% damage on genbu's shield is the only real benefit, outside of random lucky blocks (though that can be a somewhat big one).

    as far as excal goes...meh, it's free damage, that doesn't give the DDs hate. it's great for pld, but rdm not only has less acc, but less idle time. i guess it'd be good if you have one, but if not, i sure as hell wouldn't get one for rdm tanking..

  12. #132

    Sweaty Dick Punching Enthusiast

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    3,097
    BG Level
    7

    Can't find out anywhere but exactly how much -magic damage taken% is just +1 Magic Defense Bonus?(Some quick wiki research tells me -0.78125%)

    I read wiki's, "Calculating Magic Damage" and it didn't help much because it talked about damage on monsters, not PCs. But at the end of the page it shows the magic damage taken -% on Shells and each Shell V merit gives +1 Magic Defense bonus to Shell V. On the chart it said that each merit was +2/246 to damage reduced. So I beg the question, with only Shell IV how much magic damage taken -% will you need to be at the -50% magic damage taken cap? Also, wiki says RDM gets +12 magic defense bonus from traits(would that be -4.6875% magic damage taken?)

  13. #133
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    4,753
    BG Level
    7

    Quote Originally Posted by Thunder View Post
    Can't find out anywhere but exactly how much -magic damage taken% is just +1 Magic Defense Bonus?(Some quick wiki research tells me -0.78125%)

    I read wiki's, "Calculating Magic Damage" and it didn't help much because it talked about damage on monsters, not PCs. But at the end of the page it shows the magic damage taken -% on Shells and each Shell V merit gives +1 Magic Defense bonus to Shell V. On the chart it said that each merit was +2/246 to damage reduced. So I beg the question, with only Shell IV how much magic damage taken -% will you need to be at the -50% magic damage taken cap? Also, wiki says RDM gets +12 magic defense bonus from traits(would that be -4.6875% magic damage taken?)
    The two shouldn't even be considered in the same category. Magic Defense Bonus does not count towards the %Magic Damage Taken cap. That said, Shell IV is -21.9% MDT, so you would need 29% in equipment to be at the cap. Though, one thing to keep in mind is that if there is a piece of equipment that would obviously negate more damage than another, reaching the cap loses importance. An example of this would be Coral Greaves +1 versus Atartic Soleil(sp?).

  14. #134

    Sweaty Dick Punching Enthusiast

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    3,097
    BG Level
    7

    I see, thank you.

    Wiki says this about Magic Defense Bonus, "As a result, it reduces magic damage taken by a bit less than 1%. "

    I just thought that counted in the 50% cap. Again, thank you for the quick response!

    Edit: In regards to your example, Tsuko, I'm just starting to grasp this and I'm not too sure about Hexerei cape vs. Lamia mantle +1? Would the -3% damage taken count into the cap?

    Edit: One more thing, you only said that Magic Defense Bonus isn't calculated in the 50% cap. But am I right when I calculate +1Magic Defense bonus to be -0.78125% damage taken? I mean, if so, +4 MDB from Ataractic solea would only be -1.5% Magic Damage Taken(4/256). It coincides with what wiki says, "Each upgrade to the White Mage Group 2 Job-Specific Merit Points for Shellra V provides +1 Magic Defense Bonus. " and on the chart at the bottom of Calculating Magic Damage(on wiki) says that each one of those +1 MBDs on Shell V is 2/256 each, which is the aforementioned 0.78125%. I'm really curious and nobody in-game seems to be able to give me a straight answer, and I haven't been able to find a thread discussing this.

  15. #135
    Banned.

    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    4,753
    BG Level
    7

    I honestly have no idea the exact % 1 MDB reduces, I usually just follow the, "if there's more, use MDB" rule of thumb. Take that with a grain of salt though, because at high % of MDT, that's probably inaccurate.

    (I use Lamia Mantle +1)

  16. #136
    Sea Torques
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    506
    BG Level
    5

    I remember someone had a chart in their sig that shows the increasing returns of MDT- and decreasing returns of MDB. Each additional point of MDB decreases damage taken by slightly less than the previous one because it's calculated as a ratio to the caster's MAB. The more you stack it the less effective it is.

  17. #137
    Nidhogg
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    3,701
    BG Level
    7

    That was me, but I don't know what I did with that chart, and it confused some people the way I had written it, anyway.

    MDB+4 isn't 4/256 (that'd be how "magic damage taken" is calculated, for instance magic damage taken -2% is 5/256). MDB+4 with no job trait or other MDB is 1/1.04 reduction, which is -3.8%. But... Let's say you've got 2nd job trait (MDB +12) and another MDB+4 in gear, the new reduction in damage will be roughly 1.16/1.2 = a roughly 3.3% reduction from the same armor. The bonus from adding the same piece declines with the more you started with, that's what is meant by MDB not being as good as MDT (which increases in its benefit as you add more, up to the cap).

    The general rule you will hear people say, and which holds true in most situations, is that you want to cap "damage taken" and then from there add whatever MDB. Capping damage taken is somewhat difficult to explain, I came up with a system of "points" and made a comprehensive post for my LS, which I could repost or PM a copy if someone wants. But basically, to hit the cap you need 128 "points". After taking Shell into consideration, you will usually need either 60 (5/5 Shell 5) or 72 (Shell 4). Each piece's points can be determined by taking the % value listed on the piece and multiplying by 256 and rounding down. So "magic damage -4%" is .04*256 = 10.24 so 10 points. Then you add up all the points you can get from your gear, and anything above your target doesn't do anything for you, so you put in MDB or whatever else, instead. There's some exceptions to the "round down" rule, d. ring is 26 points, not 25, for instance, but for the most part it holds.

  18. #138
    CoP Dynamis
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Posts
    297
    BG Level
    4

    I've rarely, if ever, tried to make Sword/Shield tanking work on RDM. It's just more effective to dual wield chainsaws with capped parrying until my hate is capped, then swap over to Terra's.

  19. #139
    Fake Numbers
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    97
    BG Level
    2

    Quote Originally Posted by Caerloc View Post
    I've never had any really hard time tanking Byakko on RDM, elegy or no elegy. Then again i'm elvaan and generally idle in 1500-ish HP. But like i said earlier in the thread, this is a typical fight where RDM's doesnt excell.
    Idk, I've solo tanked Byakko twice as RDM and I dare to say I did excell, but then again I think RDM > (aegis) PLD for pretty much everything <_<.

    First time was as /BLU, and the dmg taken looked like this. I had taco, cocoon, phys -44/50 % and one minne I believe. Can't remember if it had Bio on or not, but the lowest hit was 37 out of 3 fights.
    For hate, I relied completely on VE, casting Blind and Bind inbetween his rounds of hits.


    Second time was as /NIN, and I found this to be a better solution if you can keep at least a Slow2 on, as that is enough to put utsu: ichi on between hits. Dmg taken ranged around 90~120.
    I did die once this time in the first fight, due to a Banish IV without shadows for 600 dmg, a Triple attack, and a Razor Fang with Triple attack proc for 500 dmg all in a matter of 3 seconds, but second fight went smooth when BLMs simply stunned all the spells.



    As for the MDB+ vs MDT- discussion, I would like to add something. Not only the two can't be compared with a simple 1:1 1:2 ratio, due to one being a % cut and the other a m.atk/mdb function, but MDT- is calculated after MDB, thus, MDB gives diminishing results the more MDT- you have. I mean:

    take a spell that does 1000 "base damage", before any correction.

    Now say you have MDB+20 and MDT-0 the damage will be:
    1000 / 1.20 - 0% = 833

    MDB+20 mitigated 167 damage with MDT-0;

    now say you have MDB+0 and MDT-50%, the damage is:
    1000 - 50% = 500

    and with MDB+20 and MDT-50%, the damage is:
    1000 / 1.20 - 50% = ~416

    This time, MDB+20 mitigated ~84 damage (half of 167, -50%) if you already have MDT-50%, because MDT "lowers" the effect of MDB, as its calculated afterwards.

    I developed some formulas (was bored while camping Fafnir <_<) to know adding how much MDB is equal to adding X MDT, and the other way around, if anyone is interested. It pretty much compares MDB vs MDT if you know your current stats.

    The formulas look as follows:

    MDB = MDT * Current MDB / (100 - Current MDT - MDT)

    and

    MDT = MDB * (100 - Current MDT) / (MDB + Current MDB)

    Example of the second formula....

    I have a Current MDT of 25 (say, shell V) and a Current MDB of 1,12 (MDB+12 from RDM Job Trait) and I want to compare MDB+4 Solea vs Coral Greaves+1 MDT-2. How much "MDT-" does MDB+4 give with the above stats?

    MDT = 0.04 * (100 - 25) / (0.04 + 1.12) = ~2.58

    Solea are better ;p

Page 7 of 7 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7

Similar Threads

  1. RDM Tanking Post 6/21 - they all give 1CE/300VE now
    By Cursed in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 224
    Last Post: 2010-07-21, 19:42
  2. RDM Tanking V2
    By Greenjade in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 54
    Last Post: 2009-04-15, 11:11
  3. SCH/RDM tanking JoL?
    By evilpaul in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 18
    Last Post: 2009-03-15, 19:18
  4. Pld/rdm Tanking Ouryu
    By Vyerz in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 43
    Last Post: 2008-09-19, 10:00
  5. RDM Tanking Experiment
    By Greenjade in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 74
    Last Post: 2008-08-28, 17:23
  6. JoL Tanking PLD/RDM
    By tuggler in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: 2008-06-08, 20:18
  7. RDM Tanking and How To Go About It?
    By Milkshakes in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 36
    Last Post: 2007-12-21, 19:08
  8. RDM/NIN tanking help
    By sleekmotorwurkz in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: 2007-09-26, 20:59
  9. JoL Tanking Rdm style
    By ghostfaced in forum FFXI: Everything
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: 2007-03-18, 01:23